The European Court of Justice (ECJ) dismissed the appeal brought by the Luxembourg beverage manufacturer B. and its subsidiary M. against the inclusion of a concentration in the European Commission’s merger control proceedings (ECJ, judgment of 8 October 2026 – C-572/25). The central issue was when the time limit of 15 working days for a referral request under Article 22(1) of Council Regulation (EC) No 139/2004 on the control of concentrations between undertakings (EU Merger Regulation, EUMR) begins.
Acquisition of a Beverage Wholesaler
B. is a Luxembourg company that produces beer and mineral water. Its wholly owned subsidiary M. operates in the beverage wholesale sector in Luxembourg, France and Belgium. H. also operates a beverage wholesale business in Luxembourg.
On 31 January 2024, B. publicly announced that the acquisition of sole control over H. had been completed. For this purpose, M. had acquired all shares in H.
Due to the absence of the required turnover, the concentration did not have an EU dimension within the meaning of Article 1 of the EUMR. Notification to the European Commission under Article 4(1) of that Regulation was therefore not required. As Luxembourg did not have its own merger control system at that time, there was likewise no notification requirement there. Nor was the concentration subject to notification in any other Member State of the European Union or in a contracting state of the European Economic Area.
Referral to the European Commission
Contacts With the Luxembourg Competition Authority
On 22 December 2023, B. informed the competition authority of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg that M. intended to acquire H. A meeting between the appellants and the authority took place on 10 January 2024.
From 17 January 2024 onwards, the competition authority received further information about the concentration from third parties. On 25 January 2024, one of those third parties formally requested that the transaction be referred to the European Commission under Article 22(1) EUMR and submitted supplementary information.
On 7 February 2024, the Luxembourg competition authority requested that the Commission examine the concentration. By decision of 14 March 2024, the Commission accepted the referral request and notified B. on the same day.
Start of the Time Limit From the Commission’s Perspective
In the Commission’s view, the referral request had been submitted within the applicable time limit of 15 working days. The competition authority had received information enabling a preliminary assessment of the conditions laid down in the first subparagraph of Article 22(1) EUMR no earlier than 17 January 2024.
The decisive factor was therefore not mere awareness of the existence of the concentration. Rather, the relevant point in time was when the authority had sufficient information about the transaction and its potential effects.
Conditions for a Referral Under Article 22 EUMR
Article 22(1) EUMR allows one or more Member States to request that the European Commission examine a concentration if three conditions are met:
-
The concentration does not have an EU dimension within the meaning of Article 1 EUMR.
-
It affects trade between Member States.
-
It threatens to significantly affect competition within the territory of the requesting Member State.
The request must be submitted no later than 15 working days after notification of the concentration. If no notification is required, the time limit begins when the concentration is otherwise made known to the Member State concerned.
The Commission may examine the concentration under Article 22(3) EUMR if it considers that trade between Member States is affected and that there is a threat of a significant adverse effect on competition within the territory of the requesting state.
Proceedings Before the General Court of the European Union
On 3 June 2024, B. and M. brought an action against the Commission’s decision. The Luxembourg competition authority and A. were granted leave to intervene in support of the Commission.
The General Court of the European Union (General Court) considered the case in early March 2025 and dismissed the action on 2 July 2025. The applicants had raised a total of eight pleas in law. One of them concerned compliance with the time limit of 15 working days.
Requirements for Making a Concentration Known
The General Court interpreted the concept of making a concentration known on the basis of the wording, regulatory context, legislative history and purpose of Article 22(1) EUMR. Due to differences between the various language versions, the wording alone could not provide a conclusive answer.
According to the General Court’s interpretation, making a concentration known formally requires the active transmission of relevant information to the competent authority of the Member State concerned. In substantive terms, the information must be sufficient to enable that authority to make a preliminary assessment as to whether the conditions for a referral request are satisfied.
It is immaterial whether the information originates from the undertakings concerned, third parties or another source. By contrast, merely communicating that a concentration exists is not sufficient.
No Obligation to Conduct Investigations of Their Own
The General Court rejected the view that the Commission and the national competition authorities must themselves actively search for information concerning concentrations that could potentially be referred. In its assessment, such an interpretation would create a considerable administrative burden and impair the effectiveness of the referral mechanism.
At the same time, the General Court held that this did not amount to a de facto notification requirement. Making a concentration known differs from a formal notification of a concentration in terms of its form, content and purpose.
In the case at hand, the General Court found that the active transmission of all necessary information to the Luxembourg competition authority before 17 January 2024 had not been established. The Commission was therefore entitled to use that date as the starting point of the time limit. The remaining pleas in law were likewise unsuccessful.
Appeal to the European Court of Justice
B. and M. requested that the ECJ set aside the judgment at first instance and annul the Commission’s decision. They based their appeal on a single ground of appeal divided into two parts.
First, they challenged the interpretation of the concept of making a concentration known. Second, they challenged the calculation of the time limit of 15 working days. In their view, the Luxembourg competition authority had obtained sufficient knowledge by 10 January 2024 at the latest, meaning that the request of 7 February 2024 had been submitted out of time.
No Prior Obligation to Provide Information
The ECJ first clarified that the General Court had not treated making a concentration known as a mandatory condition for a Member State to be permitted to submit a referral request at all. The General Court had merely determined which transmission of information triggers the 15-day time limit.
In the ECJ’s view, the appellants’ argument to the contrary was based on an incorrect understanding of the judgment at first instance.
Sufficient Information for a Preliminary Assessment
The ECJ upheld the General Court’s interpretation. The second subparagraph of Article 22(1) EUMR had to be read in conjunction with the first subparagraph. Since the latter lays down the substantive conditions for a referral, the competent authority must be able to use the information transmitted to make a preliminary assessment as to whether those conditions are met.
The active transmission must therefore contain information that enables an initial assessment, in particular, of the effects on trade between Member States and of the threat of a significant adverse effect on competition. The time limit of 15 working days does not begin until such an information basis exists.
Purpose of the Short Time Period
The ECJ also took into account that the competent national authority has only a short period in which to conduct its assessment. If general awareness of the existence of a transaction were sufficient, the authority would have to carry out extensive investigations of its own within that period to obtain the necessary information.
In the Court’s view, this would be incompatible with the effectiveness of the referral procedure and the requirements of sound administration. The Commission also requires the information transmitted because, under Article 22(3) EUMR, it must decide within ten working days after the expiry of the period for joining the request whether it will examine the concentration.
Legal Certainty Supports a Clearly Ascertainable Start of the Time Limit
The ECJ found that the interpretation it upheld did not infringe the principle of legal certainty. The start of the time limit is linked to a verifiable event: the active transmission of information that enables a preliminary assessment of the statutory conditions.
As a result, the start of the time limit does not depend on unforeseeable or uncertain circumstances, such as whether individual pieces of information are publicly available or when an authority happens to become aware of the transaction. The relevant point in time is also subject to judicial review.
Nor does the decision confer a right on national competition authorities to remain inactive. The ECJ merely held that simple awareness of the existence of a concentration does not trigger the time limit.
Distinction Between Providing Information and Notification
The appellants also argued that the General Court had treated making a concentration known as being akin to a formal notification. The ECJ rejected this part of their argument as inadmissible.
The General Court had already explained why the two procedures cannot be considered equivalent in terms of their form, content or purpose. In the ECJ’s view, B. and M. had failed to explain with sufficient precision in the appeal proceedings what error of law allegedly affected that reasoning.
The first complaint under the single ground of appeal was therefore partly inadmissible and otherwise unfounded.
Calculation of the Time Limit Not Called Into Question
The second part of the ground of appeal was also unsuccessful. The challenged calculation of the time limit depended directly on the interpretation of the concept of making a concentration known.
Since the ECJ upheld the General Court’s interpretation, there was no reason to alter 17 January 2024 as the starting date of the time limit. The referral request of 7 February 2024 was therefore not submitted out of time.
Appeal Dismissed in Its Entirety
The ECJ dismissed the appeal in its entirety. In addition to bearing their own costs, B. and M. must pay the costs incurred by the European Commission, the Luxembourg competition authority and A.
The judgment was delivered in open court in Luxembourg on 8 October 2026. The General Court’s decision that the Commission had been entitled to accept the referral request thus remained in force.
Conditional Clearance of the Concentration
In parallel with the legal dispute concerning jurisdiction, the European Commission approved B.’s acquisition of H. subject to conditions. The commitments are intended to protect competition in the supply of the hospitality sector.
An independent trustee is monitoring the implementation of the remedies. The Commission will decide on the suitability of the purchaser for the business to be divested in separate proceedings.
Significance for European Merger Control
The decision clarifies the start of the 15-working-day time limit for requests under the second subparagraph of Article 22(1) EUMR in the case of concentrations that are not subject to a national or EU notification requirement. Not every instance of awareness of a transaction triggers the time limit. What is required is the active transmission of sufficient information enabling the competent authority to make a preliminary assessment of whether the conditions for a referral are satisfied.
Companies, investors and other parties with questions concerning the scope of Article 22 EUMR, merger control or competition law proceedings can seek MTR Legal’s competition law advice.