Co-determination despite a prior closure decision
A works council elected for the first time can compel the adoption of a social plan if it was elected before the employer began implementing the operational change. A prior business decision does not in itself preclude the right of co-determination. This was clarified by the Bundesarbeitsgericht (BAG, Federal Labour Court) (BAG, decision of 17 November 2026 – 1 ABR 4/26 (case no.)).
Closure of a German banking location
The proceedings concerned the planned closure of the German location of an internationally operating bank. In August 2023, the ultimate parent company decided to consolidate its European banking business and close the German operation. The German employer implemented this group-level decision.
After the company’s management had informed the supervisory authorities, employees and the public of the intended closure, a works council was elected at the location for the first time. The election took place on 1 December 2023.
The works council asserted a right of co-determination in relation to the adoption of a social plan. Its out-of-court efforts, including referral to the conciliation committee, were unsuccessful. The employer ceased its operating activities on 8 February 2025 and closed the operation on 30 June 2025.
Dispute over the relevant point in time
In the labour court proceedings, it had to be determined whether the newly elected works council had a right of co-determination under § 112 Abs. 1 Satz 2 und Abs. 4 Betriebsverfassungsgesetz (BetrVG, German Works Constitution Act). In particular, the decisive issue was whether the closure decision that had already been made and announced precluded a mandatory social plan.
Lower courts rejected the right of co-determination
The Arbeitsgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Labour Court) had dismissed the works council’s application. The Landesarbeitsgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Higher Labour Court) likewise rejected the asserted right of co-determination.
Following the works council’s appeal on points of law, the First Senate of the BAG set aside the decision of the Landesarbeitsgericht Düsseldorf dated 23 September 2025 – 3 TaBV 39/25 (case no.). At the same time, it varied the decision of the Arbeitsgericht Düsseldorf dated 24 April 2025 – 2 BV 137/24 (case no.).
The operative part of the decision establishes that, in relation to the closure of branch D as of 31 March 2025 as part of project “M”, the works council had an enforceable right of co-determination concerning the adoption of a social plan.
Business decision alone is insufficient
According to the BAG’s decision, the right of co-determination does not cease to exist merely because, at the time of the works council election, the business decision concerning the operational change, including its key parameters, had already been made.
Commencement of actual implementation is decisive
Instead, the decisive factor is whether the employer had already begun implementing the operational change before the works council was elected. According to the BAG’s press release, the point at which implementation begins must be determined by considering all the specific circumstances of the individual case.
For the purposes of determining the relevant timeline, the following events in particular therefore had to be distinguished from one another:
- The ultimate parent company had already decided to close the German operation.
- The intended closure had been announced to the supervisory authorities, the workforce and the public.
- The works council was elected after these announcements but before implementation of the operational change began.
- The location was not actually closed until a later date.
In the BAG’s assessment, the employer had not yet begun implementing the operational change when the works council was elected. The prior communication of the intended closure to the supervisory authorities, employees and the public did not lead to a different conclusion.
Significance for the social plan procedure
The decision distinguishes the business decision-making process from the implementation of an operational change. Accordingly, the decisive factor for the right of co-determination of a works council elected for the first time is not solely when the closure decision was made or publicly announced. What matters is whether implementation of the operational change had already begun at the time of the election.
A works council elected after the fundamental business decision has been made may therefore still have an enforceable right of co-determination concerning the adoption of a social plan. The prerequisite is that it was elected before implementation began. Whether this is the case depends on all the specific circumstances of the individual case.
The timing distinction between the closure decision, its communication and its actual implementation can be of considerable importance to companies and works councils. For legal matters concerning operational changes, social plans and co-determination rights, MTR Legal advises companies and other parties as part of its employment law advisory services.