Partners in a partnership are generally entitled to information about their co-partners. This entitlement may also include disclosure of their full addresses. The relevant information enables the partners to exercise their membership rights within the partnership and to contact the other partners.
Contractual confidentiality provisions cannot automatically exclude the right to information. Whether such a provision precludes disclosure depends in particular on its specific wording and scope. This was decided by the LG Dortmund (Dortmund Regional Court), judgment of July 10, 2026 – 3 O 465/25 (case no.).
Partner Requests Information About Fellow Investors
The claimant held an indirect interest in a Kommanditgesellschaft (limited partnership) through a trust company. He was therefore not himself directly invested as a limited partner but held his interest through the trust company. His beneficial limited partnership interests had an aggregate nominal value of EUR 1,363,333. The nominal value is the face value stated for the interest.
The claimant requested the full surnames, first names and valid addresses for service of all other partners and beneficiaries. His request covered both directly invested limited partners and investors who held their interests through a trustee. For these indirect investors, he additionally requested information on the amount of their respective interests.
The claimant stated that he wished to contact his co-partners directly. In particular, he required the information in order to coordinate with other investors in advance of upcoming advisory board elections and partners’ resolutions and, where appropriate, to form voting alliances.
The defendants rejected the request for information. In support of their position, they relied, among other things, on a provision of the trust agreement governing the rights and obligations between the trust company and the beneficiaries.
Under this contractual provision, the beneficiaries were generally not entitled to information about the other beneficiaries. The agreement therefore did not provide for direct disclosure of the relevant information. Instead, it merely provided that the trust company could forward communications from individual investors to the other beneficiaries. In the defendants’ view, this forwarding option replaced a direct right to information.
The defendants also argued that some of the requested information could already be obtained from the Handelsregister (German Commercial Register). In their view, the requested details were therefore already available from a publicly accessible source.
They further asserted that disclosure of the personal data was impermissible under data protection law. The defendants thus relied on legal restrictions that might arise from the protection of the individuals concerned and their data. Finally, they argued that the request for information could constitute an impermissible exercise of rights.
LG Dortmund Largely Upholds the Claim
The Landgericht Dortmund (Dortmund Regional Court) upheld the claim almost in its entirety. It ordered the defendants, as joint and several debtors, to provide the claimant with information about all directly invested limited partners and beneficiaries. The information must include their surnames, first names and full valid addresses for service. As joint and several debtors, the defendants owe the disclosure jointly.
The disclosure obligation also extends to limited partners and beneficiaries who hold their interests indirectly through a trustee rather than directly. In this respect, in addition to the details of the investors, the amounts of their respective limited partnership contributions or beneficial contributions must also be disclosed. The information therefore covers both the ownership structure and the respective amounts of the contributions.
The information must be provided in two forms: in writing and electronically.
The court dismissed the claim only with respect to the amounts of the interests held by the directly invested limited partners. There was no entitlement to information in this regard because the amounts of the respective interests were already apparent from the Handelsregister. The relevant information was therefore accessible through the register.
The defendants must bear the costs of the proceedings based on an amount in dispute of up to EUR 140,000. The judgment is provisionally enforceable subject to the provision of security amounting to 120 percent of the sum to be enforced in each case.
Membership Rights Take Priority
The Landgericht based its decision primarily on § 166 HGB (German Commercial Code). In doing so, the chamber took account of the relevant case law of the highest courts. In particular, it referred to the order of the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice) of January 22, 2025 – II ZB 18/23 (case no.).
In that order, the BGH clarified that a partner may generally request information about the names, addresses and amounts of the interests held by their co-partners. The amount of an interest refers to the respective extent of the ownership interest under partnership law. The right to information therefore encompasses both information concerning the identity and contact details of co-partners and information concerning the extent of their interests.
This also applies where the partner intends to use the requested information to make offers to the other partners to purchase their interests. According to the BGH’s decision, such an intended use does not eliminate the fundamental right to information. The intended contact for acquisition purposes therefore does not, in itself, preclude the entitlement.
A request for information based on such grounds generally constitutes neither an impermissible exercise of rights nor an abuse of the right to information. The mere intention to acquire interests held by other partners is therefore insufficient to justify refusing disclosure.
The LG Dortmund expressly followed this case law. The opportunity to contact other partners was an inalienable membership right and therefore an integral part of partner status. This included, in particular, discussing upcoming matters before partners’ meetings and preparing coordinated voting. Contact among the partners thus enables them to exercise their membership rights jointly.
Trust Agreement Cannot Exclude the Right to Information
In the court’s view, the confidentiality provision contained in the trust agreement likewise did not preclude the right to information. Although the agreement expressly provided that the trust company was generally not permitted to provide an individual beneficiary with information about the other investors, this was intended to contractually restrict the disclosure of such information in the relationship between the trust company and the beneficiaries.
However, this contractual restriction was invalid insofar as it limited inalienable membership information rights. In the court’s view, such information rights cannot be excluded or curtailed by a confidentiality provision in the trust agreement. To this extent, the contractually agreed confidentiality obligation therefore had to give way to the right to information.
In this context, the court referred to § 166(1), sentence 2, and § 166(2) HGB in the version in force since January 1, 2024. The provision concerns membership information rights and thus constituted the statutory basis for assessing the contractual restriction.
Nor was the forwarding or mailroom solution sufficient. Although the trust company could use this method to receive communications from individual investors and forward them to the other beneficiaries, communication would take place exclusively through the trust company as an intermediary.
Such a solution therefore did not permit direct communication among the partners. Direct communication was particularly necessary to prepare advisory board elections and resolutions or to form voting alliances. This required partners to be able to contact one another and coordinate their positions without having to communicate through a central intermediary.
The mere forwarding of messages through the trust company did not guarantee such communication. It restricted the partners’ ability to exercise their membership rights jointly and directly. Their membership rights would thereby be unreasonably restricted.
Data Protection Law Does Not Preclude Disclosure
The Landgericht also rejected the defendants’ data protection concerns. It is true that the Europäischer Gerichtshof (Court of Justice of the European Union) ruled in its judgment of September 12, 2024 (joined cases C-17/22 and C-18/22) that the disclosure of data cannot automatically be based on the necessity for contract performance under Art. 6(1), first subparagraph, point (b) DSGVO (General Data Protection Regulation) where the partnership agreement expressly excludes such disclosure.
The Court referred the case back to the Amtsgericht München (Munich Local Court). The final assessment of the specific disclosure request was thus left to the national courts.
Accordingly, the assessment remains subject to review by the national courts. In particular, they must determine the legal effects of the contractual provisions under the applicable national law. In the view of the LG Dortmund, contractual restrictions are invalid where they curtail partners’ inalienable membership rights.
The chamber therefore found no conflict between European case law and the asserted right to information. European case law consequently does not preclude the review and enforcement of this right under national law.
Handelsregister Does Not Replace All Disclosures
The court drew an important distinction with regard to the directly invested limited partners. Although their surnames, first names, places of residence and the amounts of their interests can generally be obtained from the Handelsregister, the availability of this information does not mean that the claimant is required to obtain all information necessary to establish contact himself.
In particular, full valid addresses for service are not entered in the Handelsregister. A valid address for service must allow documents to be addressed with sufficient precision. Merely stating the place of residence was insufficient for this purpose and did not enable the claimant to contact his co-partners directly.
In the court’s view, it was also unreasonable to expect the claimant to determine the current addresses of all co-partners independently by making enquiries with population registers. Obtaining the information in this way would entail considerable time and expense. The general availability of individual details in the Handelsregister therefore did not replace disclosure of the full addresses.
Furthermore, the places of residence stated in the Handelsregister might no longer be current. Enquiries with population registers concerning partners living abroad might also produce no results. The place of residence stated in the Handelsregister therefore did not always enable a complete and current address to be determined. For this reason, the claimant was also entitled to disclosure of the full addresses of the directly invested limited partners.
By contrast, the court assessed the claim for information concerning the amounts of the interests held by direct limited partners differently. This information was already apparent from the Handelsregister. Moreover, any change to the liability amount must be filed for registration in the Handelsregister pursuant to § 175 HGB. The liability amount is the sum up to which the limited partner is liable to the partnership’s creditors in accordance with the statutory provisions. The claimant had no further need for information in this respect. The court therefore dismissed the claim on this point.
Practical Significance of the Judgment
The LG Dortmund judgment strengthens partners’ information and participation rights. The court confirms that partners are generally entitled to contact their co-partners directly. The right to information may therefore also include full valid addresses for service at which notices and declarations can be validly delivered. Merely indirect contact through contractually stipulated forwarding arrangements may not be sufficient. Data protection objections likewise do not generally exclude the entitlement.
When assessing the judgment, however, it must be borne in mind that it is a first-instance decision of a Landgericht. There has not yet been any official statement as to whether the judgment is final or whether an appeal has been filed. Its binding effect is therefore limited to the individual case decided. Confirmation by a higher regional court, which could contribute to further clarification of the relevant legal issues, is still pending.
The lower courts’ case law on this issue is not uniform. In its decision of July 17, 2026 (Az. 7 U 3366/25e, case no.), the Oberlandesgericht München (Munich Higher Regional Court) dismissed a beneficiary’s claim for information against the trustee limited partner on data protection grounds. The term beneficiary refers to the person on whose behalf the trustee limited partner holds the interest. The decision demonstrates that, when assessing a request for information, data protection requirements must be considered alongside the interests arising under partnership law.
A further decision of the Oberlandesgericht München of March 4, 2026 (Az. 7 U 1628/24 e, case no.) adopts the same restrictive approach. There are therefore differing assessments of the right to information at the lower-court level.
MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte advises companies, management boards, corporate officers and investors on corporate law matters and in contentious shareholder situations. Further information is available at Corporate Law Advice.