Menu

BFH: Full Inheritance Cost Allowance for Legatees

Published on November 18, 2026

In its judgment of 17 June 2026 (Az. II R 25/23, case no. II R 25/23), the Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) ruled that legatees may also claim the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance under § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 des Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetzes (ErbStG, German Inheritance and Gift Tax Act). The court further clarified that the allowance must not be reduced on a pro rata basis where, in addition to a single person subject to unlimited tax liability, there are other persons whose acquisitions are not subject to German inheritance tax.

The BFH thus strengthens the tax position of legatees and provides clarity regarding the application of the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance in cross-border succession cases.

Costs of Only EUR 13.20 Incurred

In the case at issue, the claimant received a cash legacy of 50,000 British pounds (GBP) under a testamentary disposition made by her aunt. At the time of her death in November 2019, the deceased lived in the United Kingdom. She was succeeded by her brother, who also lived there.

The estate had a total value of GBP 247,605. The claimant herself lived in Germany and was therefore subject to unlimited German inheritance tax liability in respect of her acquisition.

In her inheritance tax return, the claimant claimed a deduction of the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance applicable at the time, amounting to EUR 10,300, pursuant to § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 ErbStG. In fact, she had incurred costs of only EUR 13.20 in connection with the inheritance.

Finanzamt Does Not Apply the Allowance

However, the Finanzamt (German tax office) did not apply the allowance claimed and instead took into account only the costs actually incurred. By assessment notice dated 26 July 2021, the Finanzamt assessed inheritance tax at EUR 5,685, without applying the allowance at all.

The claimant challenged this approach and sought the full deduction of the allowance. The Finanzgericht Niedersachsen (Lower Saxony Fiscal Court) partially upheld the action in its judgment (Az. 3 K 169/21, case no. 3 K 169/21). It applied a pro rata allowance of EUR 2,080 and assessed the tax at EUR 5,385. The claimant appealed to the BFH on points of law.

BFH Largely Upholds the Appeal

The BFH largely upheld the claimant’s appeal on points of law and set aside the judgment of the Finanzgericht Niedersachsen.

In the BFH’s view, the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance under § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 ErbStG is not available exclusively to heirs. Legatees may also claim the allowance.

The court further ruled that the allowance must not be reduced on a pro rata basis where, in addition to a single person subject to unlimited tax liability, other persons are involved in the succession whose acquisitions are not subject to German taxation. In the case at issue, the claimant was therefore entitled to deduct the full allowance of EUR 10,300.

The BFH amended the inheritance tax assessment accordingly and reduced the tax to EUR 4,200. The costs of the entire proceedings were imposed on the Finanzamt.

Legatees Are Entitled to the Lump-Sum Inheritance Cost Allowance

First, the BFH clarified that legatees are also among the persons entitled to claim the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance under § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 ErbStG.

Under § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 1 ErbStG, certain estate liabilities are deductible. These include, in particular,

  • the costs of the deceased’s funeral,

  • the costs of an appropriate burial monument,

  • the customary costs of maintaining the grave

  • and the costs incurred by the beneficiary directly in connection with obtaining the acquisition.

Instead of requiring itemised evidence of these costs, § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 ErbStG permits the deduction of a statutory lump-sum allowance.

The BFH emphasised that this allowance is not available exclusively to the heir. Other beneficiaries acquiring property upon death, particularly legatees and persons entitled to a compulsory share, may also claim it.

The decisive factor is that the acquisition is an acquisition upon death that is subject to inheritance tax. The Act provides no basis for limiting the allowance to the heir under civil law.

Moreover, deduction of the allowance does not require corresponding costs to have actually been incurred at least in that amount. The very purpose of the lump-sum allowance is to dispense with the need to provide evidence of the individual cost items.

No Pro Rata Reduction Where Other Beneficiaries Are Not Taxable

The BFH also addressed whether the allowance must be reduced on a pro rata basis where, in addition to a single person subject to unlimited tax liability, other persons are involved in the succession whose acquisitions are not subject to German taxation.

The court rejected such a reduction. In the BFH’s view, the decisive factor was that the claimant’s acquisition, as the only beneficiary subject to unlimited tax liability, was fully subject to German inheritance tax. The fact that other persons also received assets from the estate, while their acquisitions were not subject to German taxation, did not justify apportioning the allowance.

Nor does § 10 Abs. 6 ErbStG lead to a different conclusion. This provision governs the deduction of debts and liabilities economically connected with non-taxable assets. It therefore concerns a different set of circumstances and cannot be applied to the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance.

Likewise, no corresponding reduction follows from § 16 Abs. 2 ErbStG. This provision concerns cases of limited tax liability and cannot be applied to the present situation involving unlimited tax liability.

The BFH therefore found no statutory basis for apportioning the allowance between taxable and non-taxable beneficiaries.

However, it confirmed that the allowance is granted only once per succession, irrespective of the number of beneficiaries. In succession cases involving several beneficiaries taxable in Germany, this means that each beneficiary is not separately entitled to the full allowance. 

Calculation of Inheritance Tax in the Case at Issue

On the basis of this legal interpretation, the BFH recalculated the inheritance tax.

The claimant’s acquisition of GBP 50,000 corresponded to EUR 58,301.56 on the relevant valuation date. The full lump-sum inheritance cost allowance of EUR 10,300 was deducted from this amount. After rounding down, this resulted in a taxable acquisition of EUR 48,000.

Taking into account the personal allowance of EUR 20,000 and the tax rate of 15 percent, the BFH assessed the inheritance tax at EUR 4,200.

Practical Significance of the Judgment

The BFH judgment of 17 June 2026 is particularly significant for the inheritance tax treatment of legacies and cross-border succession cases.

Legatees may now expressly rely on the option of claiming the lump-sum inheritance cost allowance under § 10 Abs. 5 Nr. 3 Satz 2 ErbStG. They are not required to provide evidence that costs equal to the amount of the allowance were actually incurred.

The amount of EUR 10,300 applied in the case at issue reflects the law applicable at the time of the succession in 2019. The lump-sum inheritance cost allowance has since been increased to EUR 15,000; the increased amount applies to acquisitions for which the tax arose after 31 December 2024. The amount applicable in each individual case depends on when the tax liability arose.

The decision is particularly relevant in cases where only one beneficiary is subject to unlimited German inheritance tax liability, while other heirs or beneficiaries are resident abroad and their acquisitions are not subject to German taxation.

In such cases, the allowance must not be reduced on a pro rata basis solely because other persons have an interest in the estate.

For tax advisory practice, this means that corresponding reductions made by the tax authorities must be carefully reviewed. Affected legatees and other beneficiaries acquiring property upon death should therefore ensure that the statutory allowance is taken into account in full when determining the taxable acquisition.

For matters relating to inheritance and gift tax, MTR Legal advises clients as part of its tax law advisory services.

Sources

More articles

OLG Frankfurt: Sondervotum rechtfertigt keine Aufhebung – Bild: Free-Photos / Pixabay

Litigation

Frankfurt Higher Regional Court: Dissent No Ground for Setting Aside

November 18, 2026

BGH zu Schwarzlohnzahlungen und Steuerhinterziehung – Foto: Davide Locatelli / Pexels

White-Collar Criminal Law

BGH on Undeclared Wage Payments and Tax Evasion

November 18, 2026

BGH zum übernahmerechtlichen Squeeze-out – Foto: Rafael Minguet Delgado / Pexels

Stock Corporation Law

BGH Ruling on the Takeover-Law Squeeze-Out

November 18, 2026

Book a callback

Available now15:21

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220