Menu

Frankfurt Higher Regional Court: Dissent No Ground for Setting Aside

Published on November 18, 2026

The Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main (OLG Frankfurt am Main, Frankfurt am Main Higher Regional Court) has ruled that an arbitrator’s communication of a dissenting opinion does not, in itself, justify setting aside a domestic arbitral award for a violation of procedural public policy (OLG Frankfurt am Main, order of 6 November 2026 – 32 Sch 3/26, case no. 32 Sch 3/26). The 32nd Civil Senate, which has jurisdiction over arbitration proceedings, dismissed the application to set aside the award. The decision is subject to appeal.

Dispute over the termination of a distribution agreement

In 1997, the parties entered into a distribution agreement concerning dialysis equipment. In 2018, the respondent terminated the agreement. The parties subsequently conducted arbitration proceedings concerning the validity of the termination and potential claims for damages and performance.

In October 2025, the arbitral tribunal issued the following decisions:

  • It dismissed the arbitration claim.
  • On the counterclaim, it ordered the applicant to pay approximately EUR 1.25 million in damages.
  • One of the three arbitrators issued a dissenting opinion setting out the reasons for his differing view on certain issues addressed in the arbitral award.

Both the arbitral award and the dissenting opinion were served on the parties.

Applicant alleges breach of confidentiality of deliberations

The applicant then applied to have the arbitral award set aside. Among other things, it argued that, by communicating the dissenting opinion, the arbitral tribunal had breached the confidentiality of deliberations.

The 32nd Civil Senate rejected this argument. In its assessment, there were no grounds capable of supporting the setting aside of the arbitral award. In particular, the dissenting opinion did not result in a violation of public policy requiring the award to be set aside.

Requirements for a violation of public policy

According to the OLG Frankfurt am Main, a domestic arbitral award violates procedural public policy if the arbitral tribunal has disregarded a party’s fundamental procedural right and the decision is based on that violation. The Senate found that the communication of the dissenting opinion did not satisfy these requirements.

Confidentiality of deliberations also applies to arbitrators

German arbitration law currently contains no express provision governing the admissibility of a dissenting opinion. According to the decision, however, the statutory duty to maintain the confidentiality of deliberations also applies to arbitrators.

Judges are generally required to maintain confidentiality regarding the course of their deliberations and voting. The confidentiality of deliberations safeguards judicial independence and generally precludes the public disclosure of dissenting views. However, a special provision applies to judges of the Bundesverfassungsgericht (Federal Constitutional Court), under which a dissenting view regarding a decision or its reasoning may be recorded in a dissenting opinion.

No manifest incompatibility with fundamental principles of law

In the Senate’s view, a dissenting opinion drafted only after the proceedings have concluded does not, in any event, impair the confidentiality of deliberations in a manner that would render its subsequent disclosure manifestly incompatible with fundamental principles of German law.

In reaching this conclusion, the court took into account that dissenting opinions are not entirely alien to the German legal system. By way of example, it referred to the option available at the Bundesverfassungsgericht to record in writing a dissenting view expressed during deliberations.

Moreover, by the time the dissenting opinion was disclosed, the majority of the arbitral tribunal no longer had a legitimate interest in protection from the disclosure of the differing view. The arbitral award had already been rendered at that point.

Impact on decision-making within the arbitral tribunal

The Senate also considered the potential consequences of reaching the opposite conclusion. If the mere issuance of a “dissenting opinion” were sufficient to enable an arbitral award to be set aside, the arbitrator disagreeing with the majority could thereby acquire considerable leverage.

An individual arbitrator could then use a dissenting opinion to jeopardise the finality of the majority decision. According to the OLG Frankfurt am Main, this consideration also militated against deriving a ground for setting aside an award solely from the communication of a dissenting view.

Government bill provides for an express provision

The Senate also referred to the government bill to modernise arbitration law in Bundestagsdrucksache 21/8414 (German Federal Parliament printed paper no. 21/8414). The Bundestag (German Federal Parliament) considered the bill at its first reading on 16 October 2026. The proposed provisions are not yet in force.

Dissenting opinion subject to party agreement

Under § 1054a(1) ZPO-E (draft German Code of Civil Procedure), an arbitrator is to be permitted to record a dissenting view concerning the arbitral award or its reasoning in a dissenting opinion unless the parties have agreed otherwise. This is intended to enable the parties to exclude dissenting opinions by agreement.

§ 1054a(2) ZPO-E further provides that an arbitrator should inform the other arbitrators of the intention to issue a dissenting opinion as soon as the stage reached in the deliberations permits. Notwithstanding the proposed power to do so, the explanatory memorandum to the government bill states that arbitrators remain free not to issue a dissenting opinion. As a general rule, they should also refrain from doing so.

Proposed power of publication

§ 1054b(1) ZPO-E is also intended expressly to empower the arbitral tribunal to publish an arbitral award and any dissenting opinion. With regard to dissenting opinions, the explanatory memorandum assumes that their issuance is already permissible under current law and that the new provision merely serves to clarify this point.

The OLG Frankfurt am Main also relied on this legislative assessment in support of its decision. However, this does not alter the fact that the government bill is still proceeding through the legislative process.

Significance of the decision for arbitration proceedings

The order makes clear that not every interference with the confidentiality of deliberations constitutes a violation of procedural public policy capable of justifying the setting aside of an award. The decisive issue remains whether a party’s fundamental procedural right was disregarded and whether the arbitral award was based on that disregard.

According to the decision of the OLG Frankfurt am Main, a dissenting opinion drafted after the proceedings have concluded and communicated to the parties is, in any event, insufficient for this purpose. As the order is subject to appeal, further procedural developments remain to be seen.

Companies, investors and high-net-worth individuals with questions concerning judicial review of arbitral awards or other contentious proceedings may contact MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte. Further information is available from its legal advice on litigation.

Sources

More articles

BGH zu Schwarzlohnzahlungen und Steuerhinterziehung – Foto: Davide Locatelli / Pexels

White-Collar Criminal Law

BGH on Undeclared Wage Payments and Tax Evasion

November 18, 2026

BGH zum übernahmerechtlichen Squeeze-out – Foto: Rafael Minguet Delgado / Pexels

Stock Corporation Law

BGH Ruling on the Takeover-Law Squeeze-Out

November 18, 2026

EuGH zum Fristbeginn bei Verweisungen nach Art. 22 FKVO – Foto: ELEVATE / Pexels

Competition Law

ECJ on the Start of the Time Limit for Referrals Under Article 22 EUMR

November 18, 2026

Book a callback

Available now14:38

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220