In its decision of 24 June 2026 (Az. 1 StR 552/25, case no. 1 StR 552/25), the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice) addressed the criminal liability of a de facto managing director in connection with undeclared wage payments. The case centred on the withholding and misappropriation of remuneration under § 266a StGB (German Criminal Code), tax evasion under § 370 AO (German Fiscal Code), and the relationship between the two offences for the purposes of concurrence. In addition, the BGH clarified the requirements governing the courts’ calculation of withheld social security contributions and evaded wage tax.
Undeclared wage payments over several years
The proceedings arose from the business activities of a GmbH, which employed numerous workers between October 2017 and April 2020. Although the defendant had not formally been appointed as a managing director, he in fact held the position of a de facto co-managing director. The formal managing directors were a co-defendant and another person involved.
The GmbH employed workers to whom it paid, in some cases, undeclared wages that were not officially recorded in its payroll accounts. The purpose of this approach was to increase the company’s profits and reduce its social security contributions and wage tax liabilities.
Together with the formal managing director, the defendant was involved in implementing this approach. The co-defendant concealed the undeclared wages actually paid from the tax firm responsible for preparing the monthly social security contribution reports and wage tax returns. The tax firm acted in good faith and, on the basis of the incomplete information, submitted incorrect reports to the competent authorities.
Amount of withheld social security contributions and taxes
As a result of the incomplete information, remuneration figures reported to the social security agencies between October 2017 and April 2020 were too low. Consequently, the employer’s and employees’ social security contributions were not paid in full.
Similarly, wage totals reported to the Finanzamt (German tax office) for the period from October 2017 to February 2020 were too low. For March and April 2020, the required wage tax returns were not submitted at all.
According to the findings of the Landgericht Kaiserslautern (Kaiserslautern Regional Court), the following amounts resulted:
-
Withheld social security contributions: EUR 726,343.73
-
Evaded wage tax: EUR 540,689.04
-
Underpaid solidarity surcharge: EUR 26,602.47
Based on his actual position within the company, the Landgericht regarded the defendant as a de facto co-managing director and thus as a participant bearing criminal responsibility.
BGH amends conviction and sets aside sentence
On 15 July 2025, the Landgericht Kaiserslautern had convicted the defendant (Az. 7 KLs 6065 Js 7209/21, case no. 7 KLs 6065 Js 7209/21) of withholding and misappropriating remuneration in 147 cases and tax evasion in 31 cases, imposing an aggregate term of imprisonment of three years and nine months. The defendant appealed the judgment on points of law, challenging both the legal assessment and the findings of fact.
The Bundesgerichtshof allowed the appeal in part.
Amendment of the conviction
The BGH amended the conviction to find the defendant guilty of withholding and misappropriating remuneration in 31 cases. Of these, 29 cases were committed in conjunction with tax evasion as a single act for the purposes of concurrence. There were also two cases of tax evasion.
The decisive issue was the assessment of the concurrence of offences. The Landgericht had predominantly regarded the individual offences as separate acts. By contrast, the BGH held that the withholding of remuneration and tax evasion during the respective offence period generally constitute a single act for the purposes of concurrence.
Sentence set aside
The BGH set aside the sentence in its entirety, including the underlying findings.
The case was remitted to a different Wirtschaftsstrafkammer (commercial crimes division) of the Landgericht for a new hearing and decision. In particular, that division must conduct a verifiable review of the calculation of the withheld social security contributions and evaded wage tax and determine a new sentence.
The BGH dismissed the remainder of the appeal as unfounded.
Key legal considerations of the BGH
The Bundesgerichtshof based its decision primarily on three legal considerations: the criminal liability of the de facto managing director, the relationship between § 266a StGB and § 370 AO for the purposes of concurrence, and the requirements governing the calculation of withheld contributions and evaded taxes.
De facto managing director bearing criminal responsibility
First, the BGH upheld the Landgericht’s assessment that the defendant was to be regarded as a de facto co-managing director of the GmbH. De facto management exists where a person actually assumes the management of a company and exercises decisive control over its legal transactions without having been formally appointed as a managing director.
The person concerned is not required to perform all the traditional duties of a managing director. Nor does the simultaneous involvement of a formally appointed managing director preclude a finding of de facto management. Rather, the person concerned must occupy a pre-eminent position within the company or predominantly determine its affairs.
The BGH considered these requirements to have been met in the present case. The defendant did not confine himself to his work as a dispatcher but made key business decisions jointly with the co-defendant. He was also responsible for the vehicle fleet and, in particular, for the acquisition of new trucks.
He thus occupied a prominent position within the GmbH and could be held criminally liable as a de facto co-managing director.
Criminal liability under § 266a StGB despite potential financial difficulties
The BGH also considered whether the GmbH’s financial situation could preclude criminal liability for withholding and misappropriating remuneration.
Under § 266a Abs. 1 StGB (subsection 1 of the German Criminal Code), an employer commits a criminal offence if it withholds employees’ social security contributions. This requires, however, that the employer actually and legally be in a position to pay the social security contributions owed. An obligated party cannot be required to render an impossible performance.
In this case, however, the BGH found insufficient evidence that the GmbH had been unable to pay its debts during the offence period. Rather, those responsible had deliberately made the undeclared wage payments in order to increase the company’s profits. Moreover, wages had in fact been paid both to properly registered workers and to workers who had not been properly registered.
In the BGH’s view, this weighed against a finding that the company lacked the ability to pay. Furthermore, the elements of § 266a Abs. 1 StGB had already been satisfied on the basis of a prior breach of duty.
Single act comprising withholding of remuneration and tax evasion
The BGH’s observations on the relationship between § 266a StGB and § 370 AO for the purposes of concurrence are of central importance.
The Landgericht had predominantly assessed the offences as independent offences constituting separate acts. The BGH corrected this legal classification. In the senate’s view, the withholding and misappropriation of remuneration and tax evasion generally constitute a single act for the purposes of concurrence if they relate to the same offence period and are based on a single contribution to the offence.
The decisive factor was that the co-defendant forwarded the payroll records as a single set of documents to the tax firm acting in good faith. The firm then prepared both the incorrect social security reports and the incorrect wage tax returns.
This contribution to the offence was attributable to the defendant because of his participation as a co-perpetrator. The BGH clarified that, in cases of indirect perpetration, the assessment of concurrence depends on the perpetrator’s own contribution to the offence. If the perpetrator has already made a single prior contribution that facilitates all the individual offences, the acts of the intermediary are generally attributed to the perpetrator as having been committed as a single act for the purposes of concurrence.
An exception applied, however, to March and April 2020. Although incorrect social security reports continued to be submitted in those months, no wage tax returns were filed. Consequently, there remained two instances in which the respective offences constituted separate acts.
Requirements for calculating social security contributions
Another key reason for setting aside the sentence was the inadequate explanation of the calculation of the withheld social security contributions. In the BGH’s view, it is not sufficient for a judgment merely to state the total amount of contributions that were not paid.
Instead, the bases of calculation must be presented in a comprehensible manner. These include, in particular:
-
The number of workers employed.
-
The respective periods of employment.
-
The remuneration actually paid.
-
The applicable contribution rates of the competent health insurance funds.
-
The calculation of the employer’s and employees’ shares.
If undeclared net wages are grossed up to determine gross wages, the relevant calculation factors must likewise be explained in a comprehensible manner.
Where a large number of identified workers are involved, it is not necessary to set out every individual calculation step in detail for all employees. However, representative individual cases must be provided to enable the calculations and the gross-up factors used to be reviewed.
The Landgericht’s judgment did not meet these requirements. In particular, it did not provide a comprehensible explanation of the gross-up calculation using specific workers as examples. Nor did the calculations provided by the Deutsche Rentenversicherung (German Statutory Pension Insurance Scheme) permit an adequate review.
The BGH emphasised that it was not the task of the appellate court to evaluate the extensive calculation documents itself and reconstruct the necessary calculations.
Wage tax must be calculated on the basis of the net wages actually paid
The BGH also criticised the Landgericht’s calculation in relation to tax evasion. The Landgericht had determined the amounts of evaded wage tax on the basis of grossed-up gross salaries.
In the BGH’s view, this was incorrect. Due to the receipt principle applicable under tax law, the evaded wage tax must be calculated on the basis of the net wages actually paid.
As the Landgericht had graded the individual sentences according to the respective amounts of tax evaded, it could not be ruled out that lower individual sentences would have had to be imposed if the calculation had been correct.
This error of law therefore likewise resulted in the sentence being set aside in its entirety.
Requirements for criminal liability in cases of undeclared wage payments
The BGH’s decision of 24 June 2026 illustrates several important principles governing the criminal-law assessment of undeclared wage payments.
First, the Bundesgerichtshof confirms that individuals who have not formally been appointed as managing directors may nevertheless bear criminal responsibility as de facto managing directors. Their actual position and influence over the management of the company are decisive.
Second, the BGH clarifies that the withholding of social security contributions and tax evasion may generally constitute a single act for the purposes of concurrence where they are based on a single contribution to the offence.
Finally, the requirements governing the courts’ calculation of withheld social security contributions and evaded wage tax are particularly relevant in practice. Merely stating aggregate amounts is insufficient. Instead, the bases of calculation and, in particular, any gross-up methods used must be presented in a manner that permits review by the appellate court.
The decision is therefore of considerable significance for the criminal-law investigation and adjudication of undeclared wage payments and for the requirements governing the presentation of evidence and reasoning in judgments in corresponding commercial criminal proceedings.
MTR Legal offers those affected legal advice on commercial criminal law.