Menu

Alternative Assessment of Inheritance Tax on Equitable Grounds

Inheritance tax despite no actual receipt of assets?

Published on November 16, 2026

Inheritance tax despite no actual receipt of assets?

In its judgment of 25 February 2026 (case no. II R 1/22), the Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) considered the circumstances under which an inheritance tax assessment may be adjusted on substantive equitable grounds where an heir has legally acquired assets but does not actually receive any estate assets or corresponding compensation.

The decision focuses on the tension between the valuation-date principle under inheritance tax law and the enrichment principle. The BFH clarified that an alternative assessment of inheritance tax under § 163(1), sentence 1 AO (German Fiscal Code) is possible in principle if, through no fault of their own, an heir ultimately receives no enrichment. However, the heir must prove that they took all reasonable measures to secure the estate and enforce their claims.

Heir is denied access to the estate

The judgment concerned a case in which an heir, despite having been designated as such in a will, initially obtained no actual access to the estate assets.

Dispute over heirship

The testator died in 2006 and, by a handwritten will executed in 2005, designated the subsequent claimant, the claimant’s mother and another person as heirs in equal shares.

As the competent Nachlassgericht (probate court) was initially unaware of the will, a certificate of inheritance was issued identifying the claimant’s mother and the testator’s sister as intestate heirs, each with a 50% share.

On the basis of this certificate of inheritance, the two women were able to dispose of the estate assets. It was only after protracted court proceedings that the certificate of inheritance originally issued was finally revoked in 2016. In November 2016, the claimant ultimately received a new certificate of inheritance identifying him and the two other parties as heirs, each with a one-third share.

By that time, however, the principal estate assets had already been depleted or paid out to the purported heirs.

Estate assets were completely depleted

A particularly problematic aspect was that, in addition to bank balances, the estate included the testator’s compulsory portion claim against his father, who had predeceased him. On the basis of a settlement concluded in 2013, a further EUR 250,000 arising from this compulsory portion claim had been paid to the two purported heirs.

The claimant did not learn of this until January 2017. According to his submissions, the assets had already been completely depleted by that time.

He argued that he had never had any opportunity to access the estate assets. Moreover, the two women had since become destitute and were probably residing outside Europe. He therefore considered any attempt to recover the assets they had received to be futile.

Over a period of approximately nine and a half years, the claimant had pursued court proceedings seeking the revocation of the incorrect certificate of inheritance. Requests for information addressed to the purported heirs were also unsuccessful.

Assessment of inheritance tax

By notice dated 18 December 2018, the Finanzamt (tax office) assessed inheritance tax of EUR 28,221 against the claimant. In doing so, it took into account a taxable acquisition of EUR 127,943. The calculation included, in particular, the bank balances and the testator’s compulsory portion claim.

The claimant lodged an objection and also applied for an alternative assessment of inheritance tax on equitable grounds under § 163(1), sentence 1 AO, reducing it to EUR 0. His reasoning was that, although he had legally acquired an inheritance, he had not actually received any assets whatsoever. Taxing the notional value of the estate was therefore inequitable.

The tax office rejected the application. By contrast, in its judgment of 30 June 2021 (case no. 4 K 3151/19 Erb), the Finanzgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Fiscal Court) found in the claimant’s favour with regard to the requested equitable relief and ordered the tax office to assess the inheritance tax at EUR 0. The tax office appealed this decision on points of law.

The appeal proceedings concerned only the equitable decision under § 163(1), sentence 1 AO.

BFH judgment of 25 February 2026

The BFH allowed the tax office’s appeal and set aside the judgment of the Düsseldorf Fiscal Court insofar as it had ordered the tax office to reduce the inheritance tax to EUR 0.

However, the BFH did not reject the possibility of an alternative tax assessment as a matter of principle. Rather, it clarified that an inheritance tax assessment may be reduced or even reduced entirely to EUR 0 under § 163(1), sentence 1 AO on substantive equitable grounds if, despite legally acquiring the inheritance, the heir ultimately receives no enrichment and is not at fault for this outcome.

The case was remitted to the Düsseldorf Fiscal Court for a new hearing and decision.

No automatic tax exemption where assets are not received

The BFH first clarified that the mere fact that an heir has not actually received any estate assets does not automatically result in a reduction in inheritance tax.

Instead, an overall assessment of the circumstances of the individual case is required. In particular, it must be examined whether the heir may have had claims for restitution or compensation against the persons who had appropriated the estate.

In economic terms, such claims may take the place of the original estate assets. The absence of an actual transfer of assets does not therefore necessarily mean that there has been no enrichment for inheritance tax purposes.

Remittal to the Fiscal Court

In the BFH’s view, the Düsseldorf Fiscal Court had not sufficiently examined whether the claimant held recoverable compensation claims against the two purported heirs.

Nor had it made findings as to whether it would have been reasonable for the claimant to enforce those claims in or out of court. These issues were specifically disputed between the parties.

In the second round of proceedings, the Fiscal Court must therefore examine, in particular:

  • Whether the claimant had claims for restitution or compensation.

  • Whether those claims had economic value and were actually enforceable.

  • Whether it was reasonable to expect the claimant to assert those claims.

  • Whether the purported heirs were in fact without assets.

  • Whether the claimant had taken all measures available to him to secure the estate.

Only after this examination can it be determined whether an alternative assessment of inheritance tax on equitable grounds is justified.

Interaction between the valuation-date principle and the enrichment principle

The principal significance of the decision lies in the interpretation of § 163(1), sentence 1 AO in conjunction with the valuation principles applicable under inheritance tax law.

Valuation-date principle under § 11 ErbStG

As a general rule, inheritance tax on an acquisition upon death arises upon the testator’s death pursuant to § 9(1) no. 1 ErbStG (German Inheritance and Gift Tax Act). Under § 11 ErbStG, this is also the relevant date for valuing the acquisition.

Accordingly, the relevant factor is generally the asset position on the tax valuation date. Subsequent changes in value or the later depletion of estate assets are generally disregarded in the ordinary tax assessment.

The BFH expressly confirmed this interpretation of the law. However, the valuation-date principle does not apply without limitation.

Enrichment principle under § 10(1) ErbStG

In addition to the valuation-date principle, the enrichment principle under § 10(1) ErbStG must be taken into account. Under this principle, it is generally the recipient’s enrichment that is subject to taxation.

The BFH emphasised that the interaction between these two principles may give rise to cases of exceptional hardship. If an heir is initially enriched as a matter of law but circumstances arising after the tax valuation date result in the heir ultimately receiving no economic benefit whatsoever, this may justify an alternative tax assessment.

However, this requires that the heir not be responsible for the development. This may be the case, for example, where another person unlawfully appropriates the estate, completely depletes the assets and recovery is futile because that person lacks the financial means to make restitution.

Alternative tax assessment under § 163 AO

The legal basis for such an adjustment is § 163(1), sentence 1 AO. Under this provision, taxes may be assessed at a lower amount if their collection would be inequitable in the circumstances of the individual case.

Substantive inequity exists where the tax assessment, although consistent with the wording of the law, is so contrary to the legislature’s underlying policy in the specific case that levying the tax appears inappropriate.

However, the BFH emphasised that § 163 AO does not provide a general mechanism for retrospectively correcting tax consequences prescribed by law. Rather, the provision is intended to address exceptional individual cases that were not contemplated by the legislature when designing the relevant taxation rule.

Equitable relief is therefore available only in exceptional cases.

Heir’s special duties to cooperate and provide evidence

Of particular importance are the requirements for heirs specified by the BFH. As part of an overall assessment, the heir must explain and, where necessary, prove that they did everything within their power to secure the estate.

In addition, the heir must prove that they actually asserted any potential claims for restitution or compensation.

Alternatively, the heir must demonstrate that enforcing such claims was futile from the outset, for example because the person liable to provide compensation has no assets. Merely asserting that nothing was received from the estate is therefore insufficient.

The decisive question is whether the heir exhausted all legal and practical options that could reasonably be expected of them.

The judgment is of considerable practical significance for the inheritance tax treatment of estates to which heirs are in fact denied access.

Possibility of reducing inheritance tax to EUR 0

The most important consequence is that, under certain conditions, an inheritance tax assessment may be reduced entirely to EUR 0. This applies in particular where an heir has made a taxable acquisition under the inheritance tax provisions but, through no fault of their own, has not actually received any economic enrichment whatsoever.

The BFH has therefore not created a general exception to the valuation-date principle, but has confirmed that it may be supplemented by an equitable adjustment under § 163 AO.

Claims for restitution and compensation must be examined

The significance of claims under civil law is particularly relevant in practice. Among other remedies, heirs may have claims for restitution against possessors of an inheritance under §§ 2018 et seq. BGB (German Civil Code). Claims for compensation may also be available, particularly under § 2021 BGB in conjunction with the provisions governing unjust enrichment.

As long as such claims have economic value and are enforceable, this may preclude an alternative tax assessment. Equitable relief can be considered only if enforcement is in fact futile or cannot reasonably be expected of the heir.

Documentation of all protective measures

The judgment also illustrates the importance of comprehensively documenting one’s own efforts. Heirs should maintain verifiable records of all measures taken to secure the estate and enforce their claims. These include, in particular:

  • Written demands for the restitution of estate assets.

  • Requests for information addressed to other heirs or possessors of the inheritance.

  • Evidence of court proceedings.

  • Documentation of unsuccessful enforcement or recovery attempts.

  • Evidence concerning the financial capacity of persons liable to provide compensation.

  • Evidence that potential claims cannot be enforced.

These documents may be decisive in connection with an application under § 163 AO.

No automatic adjustment of final tax assessment notices

The procedural classification is also important. § 163 AO permits an alternative tax assessment on equitable grounds. This is a separate equitable decision and is not equivalent to amending the substantive tax assessment.

An application of this kind may therefore also be relevant where the ordinary tax assessment can no longer readily be amended.

However, the requirements for equitable relief must be examined separately.

Conclusion: No inheritance tax without actual enrichment?

With its judgment of 25 February 2026 (II R 1/22), the BFH has strengthened the possibility of taking exceptional cases of hardship into account for inheritance tax purposes under § 163(1), sentence 1 AO.

The decision makes clear that the valuation-date principle under § 11 ErbStG need not result in an heir permanently having to pay inheritance tax on assets that they did not actually receive and for whose loss they were not responsible.

However, the BFH imposes stringent pleading and evidentiary requirements on taxpayers. In particular, the taxpayer must prove that they took all reasonable measures to secure the estate and enforce potential claims for restitution and compensation.

For tax practice, the judgment means that heirs who are denied access to an estate due to unlawful dispositions by third parties should not only pursue their civil-law claims but also consider seeking an alternative assessment of inheritance tax on equitable grounds under § 163 AO.

Important: In the specific dispute, the BFH did not itself reduce the inheritance tax to EUR 0. Instead, the case was remitted to the Düsseldorf Fiscal Court so that it could examine, in particular, the economic value of potential compensation claims and whether it was reasonable to expect the claimant to enforce them. Whether the claimant will ultimately be granted relief from inheritance tax therefore remains subject to the Fiscal Court’s new decision.

For questions concerning inheritance and gift tax, MTR Legal advises clients as part of its tax law advisory services.

Sources

More articles

BGH stärkt Makler: Provision trotz Widerrufs möglich – Foto: Thirdman / Pexels

Real Estate Law

BGH Strengthens Brokers: Commission Despite Revocation

November 16, 2026

BGH setzt Wert der OBI-Farbmarke auf 2,5 Millionen Euro – Foto: Andy Brown auf Unsplash

IP Law

BGH Sets Value of OBI Colour Mark at €2.5 Million

November 16, 2026

Einstweiliger Rechtsschutz trotz Schiedsklausel – Foto: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Contract Law

Interim Relief Despite an Arbitration Clause

November 16, 2026

Book a callback

Available now17:47

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220