Menu

Interim Relief Despite an Arbitration Clause

Published on November 16, 2026

The decision of the Bundesverfassungsgericht (BVerfG, Federal Constitutional Court) of 22 June 2026 (Case No. 1 BvR 2696/25) demonstrates that the precedence of a statutory arbitration procedure must not result in a service provider being denied all interim relief. In particular, the Sozialgerichte (social courts) must consider whether awaiting the decision in the principal proceedings would cause serious harm that could not subsequently be remedied.

Insolvency administrator lodges constitutional complaint

The proceedings arose from the constitutional complaint of an insolvency administrator who administered the assets of a GmbH operating in the field of out-of-hospital intensive care.

The remuneration for the services provided by the GmbH to persons covered by statutory health insurance was initially governed by a transitional agreement pursuant to § 132l Abs. 5 SGB V (Book V of the German Social Code). This agreement originally applied from 1 July 2024 to 30 June 2025 and was subsequently extended until 30 September 2025.

For further remuneration, a new agreement had to be concluded with the regional associations of the health insurance funds and the substitute health insurance funds. However, the relevant negotiations failed due to differing views concerning the level of remuneration per hour of care.

Duration of arbitration procedure unforeseeable

As the contracting parties were unable to reach an agreement, a mandatory arbitration procedure had to be conducted pursuant to § 132l Abs. 6 SGB V. Its duration, however, could not be foreseen.

This created a considerable financial problem for the GmbH: it continued to provide out-of-hospital intensive care services but had no secure basis for remuneration that covered the costs of its services.

To safeguard the company’s economic survival while the arbitration procedure was pending, the GmbH applied to the Sozialgericht Dresden (Dresden Social Court) for interim relief. Its objective was to obtain a provisional determination of adequate remuneration for the care services provided.

By decision of 8 September 2025 (Case No. S 15 KR 453/25 ER), the Sozialgericht Dresden dismissed the application. The Sächsisches Landessozialgericht (Saxon Higher Social Court) also dismissed the appeal by decision of 3 November 2025 (Case No. L 9 KR 221/25 B ER). Its reasoning was essentially that the statutory arbitration procedure first had to be awaited. Until that procedure had been concluded, the claim in the principal proceedings lacked sufficient prospects of success.

In reaching this conclusion, the Landessozialgericht relied in particular on the judgment of the Bundessozialgericht (BSG, Federal Social Court) of 14 July 2022 (Case No. B 3 KR 2/22 R). The Landessozialgericht did not consider it necessary to assess separately the service provider’s fundamental rights or to conduct a corresponding balancing of consequences.

The subsequent objection alleging a violation of the right to be heard was dismissed by a further decision of the Landessozialgericht. The insolvency administrator then lodged a constitutional complaint with the Bundesverfassungsgericht.

Right to effective judicial protection

In particular, he alleged a violation of the right to effective judicial protection under Art. 19 Abs. 4 Satz 1 GG (German Basic Law). He also alleged a violation of the general right of access to justice, the principle of a fair trial and the freedom of occupation under Art. 12 Abs. 1 GG.

During the proceedings, he partially withdrew the constitutional complaint insofar as it directly challenged the failure to conclude the agreement and a prohibition imposed by the health insurance funds on the provision of services.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht therefore had to decide, in particular, on the constitutionality of the Landessozialgericht’s refusal to grant interim relief.

Decision of the Bundesverfassungsgericht

The Bundesverfassungsgericht partially upheld the constitutional complaint in a chamber decision. In its decision of 22 June 2026, the court held that the decision of the Sächsisches Landessozialgericht of 3 November 2025 violated the complainant’s fundamental right to effective judicial protection under Art. 19 Abs. 4 Satz 1 GG.

The contested decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Sächsisches Landessozialgericht for a new hearing and decision. As a consequence of the decision being set aside, the Landessozialgericht’s decision dismissing the objection alleging a violation of the right to be heard also became moot.

Following the remittal, the Sächsisches Landessozialgericht must now examine whether, and under what conditions, the intensive care service must be provisionally safeguarded until the arbitration procedure has been concluded.

In all other respects, the Bundesverfassungsgericht declined to admit the constitutional complaint for adjudication.

It also ordered the Land Sachsen (Free State of Saxony) to reimburse the complainant for his necessary expenses incurred in the constitutional complaint proceedings.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht therefore expressly did not decide on the specific amount of appropriate remuneration or on a definitive entitlement to the conclusion of a particular remuneration agreement. Instead, it held that the Landessozialgericht had dismissed the application for interim relief in breach of constitutional requirements.

The matter therefore had to be reconsidered in compliance with the constitutional requirements.

This task now falls to the Sächsisches Landessozialgericht, which, according to the same information, must examine whether, and under what conditions, the intensive care service must be provisionally safeguarded until the arbitration procedure has been concluded. The successful constitutional complaint therefore initially gives the service provider only the right to a fresh, constitutionally compliant review of its application for urgent relief, rather than an entitlement to provisional remuneration.

Violation of the right to effective judicial protection

The principal significance of the decision lies in the interpretation and application of Art. 19 Abs. 4 Satz 1 GG. The Bundesverfassungsgericht first clarified that this provision guarantees a fundamental right to effective and, as far as possible, comprehensive judicial protection against acts of public authority.

The protection afforded by this fundamental right is not limited to the mere possibility of bringing a matter before a court. Rather, the courts must also ensure that the rights concerned are effective in practice. A legal remedy must therefore not be structured or applied in such a way that it becomes practically ineffective for the person concerned.

According to the Bundesverfassungsgericht, this expressly also applies where the matter at issue is not interference with an existing legal position but the denial of a statutory entitlement to benefits.

Need for interim relief where irreparable harm is imminent

The Bundesverfassungsgericht stated that the guarantee of effective judicial protection generally also encompasses the availability of urgent proceedings. Such interim relief is necessary, in particular, where the person concerned would otherwise face a serious violation of rights that could no longer be remedied by a subsequent decision in the principal proceedings.

In interim relief proceedings, the Sozialgerichte may generally base their decisions both on a summary assessment of the prospects of success in the principal proceedings and on a balancing of consequences. In doing so, however, they must take account of the significance of the fundamental rights concerned.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht emphasised in particular, in substance: The more serious the harm resulting from a refusal of interim relief and the less likely it is that such harm could be remedied if the applicant subsequently prevailed in the principal proceedings, the less the interest in a provisional arrangement may be subordinated.

Significance of economic consequences

The court thus made it clear that the economic consequences of a judicial decision in urgent proceedings must not be treated as merely secondary.

Rather, the Sozialgerichte must examine the specific consequences that awaiting the decision in the principal proceedings would have for the service provider concerned.

Precedence of arbitration does not preclude interim relief

A key focus of the decision concerns the relationship between the mandatory arbitration procedure under § 132l Abs. 6 SGB V and interim judicial relief. The Landessozialgericht had based its dismissal primarily on the fact that the statutory arbitration procedure first had to be conducted.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht rejected this blanket approach. It clarified that the case law of the Bundessozialgericht, according to which an action for payment brought by a service provider against a health insurance fund may be dismissed as currently unfounded while an arbitration procedure is still pending, cannot automatically be applied to interim relief proceedings.

In particular, this case law does not state that interim judicial protection is generally excluded while an arbitration procedure is pending.

Rather, where no agreement has been concluded, it is generally possible to apply to the Sozialgerichte for an interim regulatory order. According to the Bundesverfassungsgericht, there is no statutory provision that would preclude such an approach.

The mandatory arbitration procedure and interim judicial relief are therefore not mutually exclusive.

Instead, the Sozialgerichte must examine in each individual case whether, despite the pending arbitration procedure, a provisional judicial arrangement is necessary to prevent serious and unreasonable harm.

Consideration of the financially existential situation

The Bundesverfassungsgericht attached particular importance to the specific financial situation of the GmbH concerned. In the present case, the unresolved remuneration situation threatened the service provider with complete economic collapse.

In the meantime, the situation threatening the company’s existence had even materialised in the opening of insolvency proceedings over the GmbH’s assets. The Bundesverfassungsgericht held that, in these circumstances, the unconditional refusal of interim relief resulted in serious and unreasonable harm.

It was particularly problematic that even subsequent success in the arbitration procedure or in the principal proceedings might no longer have been capable of remedying the financial damage already incurred.

If the insolvency proceedings had ended with the dissolution of the GmbH, a subsequent judicial decision in favour of the service provider would have lost its practical effect. A retrospective determination of an entitlement to remuneration would then no longer have been able to save the company’s economic existence.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht therefore emphasised that, precisely in such circumstances, the courts must include the situation threatening the company’s existence in their constitutional assessment.

It was therefore insufficient merely to refer to the precedence of the arbitration procedure.

Obligation to conduct a balancing of consequences

Another key criticism raised by the Bundesverfassungsgericht concerned the Landessozialgericht’s failure to conduct a balancing of consequences. The Landessozialgericht had essentially declined to conduct a judicial review on the grounds that the arbitration procedure first had to be awaited.

As a result, it had not adequately considered the consequences that the refusal of interim relief would have for the service provider.

According to the Bundesverfassungsgericht, the Landessozialgericht should at least have examined whether the case law of the Bundessozialgericht concerning the precedence of arbitration could also apply without restriction in a situation in which the complete loss of the undertaking’s economic existence, and thus the permanent frustration of the exercise of fundamental rights, was imminent.

As the outcome of the principal proceedings was uncertain and a final determination of the facts and legal issues did not appear possible in the urgent proceedings, the balancing of consequences required under constitutional law should have been conducted.

The complete denial of judicial authority to review the matter on the basis of the precedence of the arbitration procedure was therefore incompatible with Art. 19 Abs. 4 Satz 1 GG. The Bundesverfassungsgericht held that it could not be ruled out that the Landessozialgericht would have reached a different decision had it taken these constitutional requirements into account.

Further procedural considerations

In addition to considering the merits of the constitutional complaint, the Bundesverfassungsgericht also addressed its admissibility.

In particular, it clarified that the opening of insolvency proceedings over the GmbH’s assets did not preclude the insolvency administrator’s standing to lodge the complaint. By virtue of his status as a party acting ex officio, the insolvency administrator is entitled to allege the asserted violations of fundamental rights in his own capacity.

Principle of subsidiarity did not preclude the constitutional complaint

Nor did the principle of subsidiarity preclude the constitutional complaint. Although this principle generally requires all reasonable procedural avenues to be exhausted before a constitutional complaint is lodged,

in the specific case, the alleged violation of fundamental rights concerned the very refusal of interim relief. Subsequent principal proceedings could not have remedied this specific grievance because they would only have examined the lawfulness of the arbitration board’s decision.

Insofar as the constitutional complaint challenged the decision of the Sozialgericht Dresden, however, it was not admitted for adjudication. That decision had been procedurally superseded by the subsequent decision of the Landessozialgericht.

The decision of the Bundesverfassungsgericht of 22 June 2026 is of considerable importance to service providers in the field of out-of-hospital intensive care and, more broadly, to comparable situations under social benefits law.

The decision makes clear that a statutory arbitration procedure must not result in affected service providers being denied all urgent judicial protection for the duration of that procedure.

Particularly where a situation threatens the undertaking’s economic existence, the Sozialgerichte must examine whether a provisional judicial arrangement is necessary to avert serious and irreversible harm.

In particular, the following principles can be derived from the decision:

  • No general exclusion of interim relief: A pending mandatory arbitration procedure under § 132l Abs. 6 SGB V does not generally preclude the possibility of obtaining an interim regulatory order from a court.

  • Separate assessment of interim relief: The case law of the Bundessozialgericht concerning the precedence of arbitration in actions for payment cannot automatically be applied to interim relief proceedings.

  • Consideration of threats to economic existence: The Sozialgerichte must take account of the specific economic consequences of their decisions, particularly where the service provider faces insolvency or the complete cessation of its operations.

  • Obligation to balance the consequences: Where serious and irreversible harm is imminent, a decision must not be based exclusively on the fact that the arbitration procedure is still pending.

  • Guarantee of effective judicial protection: Art. 19 Abs. 4 Satz 1 GG requires judicial protection not merely to be formally available but also to remain genuinely capable of protecting the rights concerned.

The decision makes clear that, although a statutory arbitration procedure may in principle take precedence, that precedence must not result in a service provider becoming financially incapable of operating before the arbitration procedure has been concluded and subsequently being unable to obtain effective redress even through a decision in its favour in the principal proceedings.

In business transactions, contracting parties frequently agree on an arbitration clause. These clauses serve to resolve the principal dispute, but they generally cannot protect against immediately impending harm. In such cases, interim relief from the state courts plays an important role.

MTR Legal advises companies on arbitration clauses and other matters of contract law. Further information is available at Legal advice on contract law.

Sources

More articles

BGH stärkt Makler: Provision trotz Widerrufs möglich – Foto: Thirdman / Pexels

Real Estate Law

BGH Strengthens Brokers: Commission Despite Revocation

November 16, 2026

Abweichende Festsetzung der Erbschaftssteuer aus Billigkeitsgründen – Foto: Михаил Крамор / Pexels

Tax Law

Alternative Assessment of Inheritance Tax on Equitable Grounds

November 16, 2026

BGH setzt Wert der OBI-Farbmarke auf 2,5 Millionen Euro – Foto: Andy Brown auf Unsplash

IP Law

BGH Sets Value of OBI Colour Mark at €2.5 Million

November 16, 2026

Book a callback

Available now17:47

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220