Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice) Judgment of 16 July 2026 – I ZR 223/25 (case no.)
In its judgment of 16 July 2026 (Az. I ZR 223/25), the Bundesgerichtshof clarified important questions concerning brokers’ commission on the sale of single-family homes. The central issue was whether a real estate broker may claim commission from the buyer if the seller has validly revoked the brokerage agreement and is therefore not required to pay commission.
The BGH answered this question in the affirmative. Such revocation does not automatically extinguish the commission claim against the buyer. The Court also clarified that a single-family home held under a hereditary building right is covered by § 656a BGB (German Civil Code). Furthermore, sending a property brochure containing an unequivocal request for commission may itself result in the conclusion of a valid brokerage agreement in text form.
Broker Claims Commission from Buyer
In spring 2022, a member of a community of heirs instructed a real estate broker to sell a property in Berlin. The property was a mid-terrace house situated on land subject to a hereditary building right.
The broker agreed with the seller’s side on commission amounting to 3 per cent of the purchase price plus VAT, totalling 3.57 per cent.
The broker subsequently prepared a property brochure. It offered the building for EUR 292,800 and the land for EUR 102,200. The brochure also contained an unequivocal notice stating that the buyer would be required to pay commission of 3.57 per cent. Prospective buyers were also given the option of assuming the existing hereditary building right agreement.
Brokerage Agreement with the Buyer
On 9 August 2022, the prospective buyer requested the property brochure via a real estate portal. The parties had previously spoken by telephone.
On 13 August 2022, the prospective buyer viewed the property. He subsequently signed an agreement confirming that the broker had introduced him to the opportunity to purchase the property and undertaking to pay brokerage commission of 3.57 per cent if he acquired it. A notice of the right of revocation was attached to this agreement.
Seller Revokes the Brokerage Agreement
The situation on the seller’s side developed differently: the representative of the community of heirs revoked the brokerage agreement on 19 September 2022. The reason was that the broker had not provided notice of the right of revocation when the agreement was concluded. The broker was therefore unable to enforce a commission claim against the seller’s side.
On 25 May 2023, the prospective buyer and his wife jointly purchased the hereditary building right, including the house erected on the land. The purchase price was EUR 270,000. The broker then invoiced the buyer for commission of EUR 9,639. However, the buyer refused to pay.
Procedural History
The Landgericht Berlin II (Berlin Regional Court II) initially upheld the broker’s claim. The Kammergericht Berlin (Berlin Higher Regional Court) overturned that decision and dismissed the action. It reasoned that the statutory rule on the division of brokerage costs under § 656c BGB would be circumvented if the broker could not enforce its commission claim against the seller while continuing to demand the full agreed commission from the buyer.
The broker then appealed on points of law to the Bundesgerichtshof.
BGH Confirms Commission Claim
The Bundesgerichtshof allowed the broker’s appeal on points of law (judgment of 16 July 2026, Az. I ZR 223/25). The Court overturned the judgment of the Kammergericht and reinstated the first-instance decision of the Landgericht Berlin II. The buyer must therefore pay the broker the claimed amount of EUR 9,639.
In particular, the BGH established three key principles:
-
A single-family home held under a hereditary building right is a single-family home within the meaning of § 656a BGB.
-
A property brochure containing an unequivocal notice of the commission demanded from the buyer may itself constitute an offer to conclude a brokerage agreement in text form.
-
Valid revocation of the brokerage agreement by one party to the purchase agreement does not automatically extinguish the broker’s commission claim against the other party.
Reasons for the Judgment: Why the Broker May Claim Commission
The BGH based its decision primarily on §§ 652, 656a and 656c BGB.
Hereditary Building Right Does Not Preclude the Application of § 656a BGB
The BGH first had to determine whether the statutory provisions governing brokerage agreements for single-family homes applied at all.
Under § 656a BGB, brokerage agreements concerning the brokering of, or introduction to, an opportunity to conclude a purchase agreement for an apartment or a single-family home must be made in text form. The BGH clarified that classification as a single-family home does not depend on the legal structure of the acquisition of the land.
Instead, the actual characteristics of the property are decisive. A mid-terrace house is a single-family home within the meaning of the provision. The fact that the building was erected on the basis of a hereditary building right does not alter this conclusion.
The provisions of §§ 656a et seq. BGB therefore also apply to corresponding property transactions involving hereditary building rights.
Property Brochure May Itself Establish a Brokerage Agreement
Another central issue in the decision was whether a valid brokerage agreement had been concluded between the broker and the buyer at all. Under § 656a BGB, such an agreement must be concluded in text form. The applicable requirements are set out in § 126b BGB.
The BGH clarified that a brokerage agreement may still be concluded by conduct demonstrating an intention to be legally bound. The text-form requirement does not preclude the implied conclusion of an agreement.
However, certain requirements apply: the broker must make it unequivocally clear that commission is being demanded from the prospective buyer and that the broker is not merely acting on behalf of the seller. A property brochure containing a clear notice of the commission payable by the buyer may itself constitute a corresponding contractual offer.
In this case, the property brochure contained an unequivocal notice stating commission of 3.57 per cent. The buyer had requested the brochure and subsequently arranged a viewing. In the BGH’s view, the requirements for a valid brokerage agreement in text form were therefore satisfied.
The subsequent written commission agreement confirmed the agreement that had already been concluded.
Revocation by the Seller Does Not Affect the Buyer’s Commission Obligation
The BGH’s reasoning concerning the application of § 656c BGB is particularly significant. Under this provision, a broker acting for both parties to an agreement for the purchase of an apartment or a single-family home must agree commission of the same amount with both parties.
This principle of equal division is intended to prevent brokerage costs from being shifted unilaterally to the buyer. In this case, both the seller’s side and the buyer had agreed to pay commission of 3.57 per cent each. The original commission agreements therefore complied with the statutory requirements.
In the BGH’s view, the fact that the broker was subsequently no longer able to enforce its claim against the seller’s side did not automatically invalidate the brokerage agreement with the buyer.
No Extinguishment by Analogy with § 656c BGB
The Kammergericht had assumed that the commission claim against the buyer had to be extinguished. To reach this conclusion, it had applied § 656c(1), sentence 3 BGB by analogy. This provision stipulates that a waiver or subsequent reduction of the commission claim against one party generally also benefits the other party.
However, the BGH rejected such application by analogy. The decisive factor for the Court was that the broker had not voluntarily waived the commission owed by the seller’s side. Rather, the seller’s side had itself validly revoked the brokerage agreement.
The broker had negligently failed to provide the seller’s side with proper notice of its right of revocation. It was therefore still able to validly revoke the agreement on 19 September 2022. In the BGH’s view, this did not constitute a waiver of commission by the broker.
§ 656c(1), sentence 3 BGB applies in particular to cases in which the broker itself waives or reduces its commission claim by agreement with one of the contracting parties. That was specifically not the case here.
No Unintended Gap in the Law
The BGH also examined whether § 656c BGB could be applied by analogy due to an unintended gap in the law. The panel rejected this as well.
When introducing the provision, the legislature had intended in particular to prevent brokers from offering their services to sellers free of charge and subsequently demanding the entire commission from buyers. The principle of equal division was intended to prevent precisely such arrangements.
By contrast, the legislature had taken into account that, for various reasons, a broker might only be able to enforce its commission claim against one contracting party.
The complete extinguishment of the commission claim against the other party was expressly not provided for in such cases. Valid revocation by the seller therefore does not also release the buyer from its payment obligation.
Significance of the Judgment for Real Estate Brokers and Buyers
The BGH judgment of 16 July 2026 is of considerable practical significance for real estate brokerage.
Significance for Real Estate Brokers
Brokers may rely on the decision if they have concluded brokerage agreements requiring payment of commission with both the seller and the buyer and one party subsequently validly revokes its agreement.
The commission claim against the other party generally remains enforceable, provided that the original agreements comply with the statutory requirements.
At the same time, the decision highlights the importance of providing proper notice of the right of revocation. Errors in the notice may cause a broker to lose its commission claim against one contracting party.
The drafting of property brochures is also becoming more important: an unequivocal notice of the commission payable by the buyer may itself constitute a valid contractual offer in text form.
Significance for Property Buyers
For prospective buyers, the judgment means that they cannot readily rely on the seller’s revocation of the brokerage agreement. If they have themselves concluded a valid brokerage agreement and the purchase agreement was concluded as a result of the broker’s services, they may remain independently liable to pay commission.
This also applies if the broker can no longer demand commission from the seller.
Conclusion
With its judgment of 16 July 2026 (Az. I ZR 223/25), the BGH has provided clarity on the application of the principle of equal division under § 656c BGB.
Valid revocation of a brokerage agreement by the seller does not automatically extinguish the commission claim against the buyer. The decisive question is whether the broker itself waived its commission or whether the extinguishment of the claim resulted from an independent declaration by the other contracting party.
The BGH also clarified that single-family homes situated on land subject to hereditary building rights are covered by § 656a BGB and that a property brochure containing an unequivocal request for commission may itself establish a brokerage agreement in text form.
In practice, the judgment means that the principle of equal division protects buyers against deliberate circumvention of the statutory allocation of commission, but does not automatically extinguish their own commission obligation if the seller validly revokes its brokerage agreement.
MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte advises buyers and sellers on legal matters relating to property purchases. Further information is available under legal advice on real estate law.