Menu

BGH Sets Value of OBI Colour Mark at €2.5 Million

Published on November 16, 2026

Der Bundesgerichtshof hat den Gegenstandswert der anwaltlichen Tätigkeit im Rechtsbeschwerdeverfahren über die abstract orange colour mark at €2.5 million (BGH, order dated 6 November 2026 – I ZB 58/25). This amount is therefore considerably higher than the standard value of €50,000 considered appropriate by OBI, but significantly lower than the €10 million sought by the applicants.

Dispute over the continued validity of the colour mark

The proceedings concerned abstract colour mark no. 30 2010 036 738. After the Bundesgerichtshof had dismissed OBI’s appeal against the decision of the Bundespatentgericht (Federal Patent Court) (BGH, order dated 17 September 2026 – I ZB 58/25), the applicable value still had to be determined.

The applicants sought to have the value set at €10 million. By contrast, OBI considered the standard value of €50,000, which is regularly applied in trade mark cancellation proceedings, to be sufficient.

Trade mark proprietor’s economic interest is decisive

Intensive use may justify a higher value

According to the First Civil Senate, the value must be assessed on the basis of the trade mark proprietor’s economic interest in the continued validity of the mark. Although the value in proceedings concerning the cancellation of a trade mark is generally €50,000, a substantially higher amount may be justified where a mark is used intensively.

Relevant indicators include, in particular, the extent to which the mark is used and the amount spent on advertising. In OBI’s case, the Bundesgerichtshof identified several circumstances indicating a substantial economic interest:

  • The DIY retail group has been the market leader in the retail sale of building and home improvement products for decades.
  • The colour orange is used in numerous stores, as well as on employees’ clothing and shopping trolleys.
  • OBI generates annual revenue of several billion euros in Germany.
  • The company spends amounts in the high tens or hundreds of millions on advertising in which orange is used.

Limited significance of revenue and advertising expenditure

Orange is frequently combined with other signs

However, the Bundesgerichtshof did not consider these financial figures to be conclusive without qualification. In many cases, OBI does not use orange on its own, but together with the company name or in combination with other colours.

Moreover, other DIY chains also use orange, without OBI having taken action against such use on the basis of the abstract colour mark. Revenue and advertising expenditure could therefore be taken into account only to a limited extent when assessing the colour mark in isolation.

Nevertheless, when viewed as a whole, the circumstances demonstrated that OBI had a substantial interest in maintaining the registration. The value was therefore set at €2.5 million.

No higher valuation under the principles applicable to patents

The Bundesgerichtshof’s case law on determining the value in patent invalidity proceedings also did not result in a higher amount. In such proceedings, the fair market value of the patent and any damages claims that have already arisen are generally taken into account.

The Bundesgerichtshof left open whether these principles can be applied to trade mark cancellation proceedings. In any event, no further valuation was warranted in this particular case because OBI had not initiated infringement proceedings based on the abstract colour mark and had not asserted any resulting claims for damages.

Significance of the decision for trade mark protection

The determination makes clear that the value of trade mark cancellation proceedings involving intensively used signs may be considerably higher than the standard value of €50,000. At the same time, the decision shows that high revenue and substantial advertising expenditure cannot automatically be attributed in full to the trade mark concerned if the sign is predominantly used together with other means of identification.

Companies and trade mark proprietors with questions concerning the registration, use or defence of colour marks and other signs can contact MTR Legal. Further information is available under Legal Advice on IP Law.

Sources

More articles

BGH stärkt Makler: Provision trotz Widerrufs möglich – Foto: Thirdman / Pexels

Real Estate Law

BGH Strengthens Brokers: Commission Despite Revocation

November 16, 2026

Abweichende Festsetzung der Erbschaftssteuer aus Billigkeitsgründen – Foto: Михаил Крамор / Pexels

Tax Law

Alternative Assessment of Inheritance Tax on Equitable Grounds

November 16, 2026

Einstweiliger Rechtsschutz trotz Schiedsklausel – Foto: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Contract Law

Interim Relief Despite an Arbitration Clause

November 16, 2026

Book a callback

Available now17:47

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220