OLG Frankfurt am Main (Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main), judgment of 19 August 2026 – 17 U 141/25 (case no. 17 U 141/25)
The Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main ruled that a standard-form co-liability clause in a lease transfer agreement may be surprising and therefore invalid. As a general rule, an outgoing lessee is not required to expect that, after the lease agreement has been transferred, they will remain liable for the new lessee’s obligations. Of particular importance are the structure of the agreement and the failure to highlight the co-liability clause.
Dispute over liability following a lease transfer
The defendant had leased a car from the claimant. A former roommate of the defendant wished to use the vehicle herself in the future and therefore intended to take over the existing lease agreement. For this purpose, the parties entered into a lease transfer agreement, which also had to be signed by the outgoing lessee.
The standard terms and conditions of the transfer agreement contained a clause under which the outgoing lessee was to remain jointly liable for all present and future obligations arising from the lease agreement. This was intended to ensure that her original contractual liability would not cease entirely despite the transfer of the agreement.
After the new lessee fell into arrears with the lease payments, the lessor asserted a claim against the outgoing lessee on the basis of the agreed co-liability clause.
The Landgericht Frankfurt am Main (Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main) initially upheld the action in its judgment of 11 November 2025 (Az. 2-19 O 586/23, case no. 2-19 O 586/23) and ordered the outgoing lessee to pay just under EUR 20,000. The defendant appealed against this judgment.
OLG Frankfurt dismisses the action
The Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main allowed the defendant’s appeal and dismissed the action in its entirety.
In the court’s view, the lessor had no claim against the outgoing lessee for payment of the outstanding lease instalments. The co-liability clause contained in the lease transfer agreement was surprising within the meaning of § 305c Abs. 1 BGB (German Civil Code) and had therefore not become part of the agreement.
Under this provision, clauses in standard terms and conditions do not become part of an agreement if, in the circumstances, particularly in view of the external appearance of the agreement, they are so unusual that the other party to the contract with the user of the terms could not reasonably be expected to anticipate them.
In particular, the court found that a lessee who transfers a lease agreement to another person by way of a transfer of contract may generally assume that they will be fully released from their existing obligations under the lease.
The decision is final and not subject to appeal.
Co-liability clause as a surprising standard term
The decision of the OLG Frankfurt am Main is based primarily on the application of § 305c Abs. 1 BGB and the question of whether the co-liability clause was surprising for the outgoing lessee.
Legitimate expectations of the outgoing lessee
First, the court considered the typical interests involved in a transfer of contract. A person who transfers a lease agreement with the aim of withdrawing from it generally expects that they will no longer be liable for the contractual obligations in the future.
According to the court’s reasoning, the expectation of a lessee who enters into a transfer agreement with the transferee and the lessor for the purpose of withdrawing from a lease agreement is that they will be fully released from the obligations under the lease.
Continued liability for the new lessee’s obligations was contrary to this legitimate expectation.
This applied in particular because, following the transfer of the agreement, the outgoing lessee generally no longer had any influence over the use of the leased asset or the subsequent course of the contractual relationship. In particular, the outgoing lessee could not monitor whether the new lessee was duly meeting her payment obligations.
Designation of the agreement weighs against continuing liability
In addition, the OLG considered the external appearance of the lease transfer agreement. In the court’s view, its designation as a “transfer agreement” [translated] did not, in itself, suggest that the outgoing lessee would remain liable.
The terms “outgoing lessee” and “transferee” [translated] used in the agreement likewise indicated that the contractual obligations were to pass to the new lessee and that the outgoing lessee would withdraw from the contractual relationship. This terminology suggested a complete substitution of one contracting party for another.
The co-liability clause was therefore inconsistent with the understanding that an average contracting party was entitled to form on the basis of the structure and designation of the agreement.
Failure to visually highlight the co-liability clause
Another key consideration was the specific layout of the contractual form. According to the court’s findings, the declaration of co-liability was neither specially highlighted nor clearly separated spatially from the remaining contractual text. Instead, it was fully incorporated into the text of the transfer agreement.
In the OLG’s view, clear visual emphasis or spatial separation from the main agreement could have helped the outgoing lessee recognise the far-reaching significance of the clause.
Such a layout could have reduced the risk of the outgoing lessee being taken by surprise.
However, because the clause did not stand out due to either its placement or its presentation, and the remainder of the agreement likewise contained no indication of continuing co-liability, the outgoing lessee was not required to anticipate such a provision.
The clause was therefore to be regarded as a surprising term within the meaning of § 305c Abs. 1 BGB.
Co-liability clause does not become part of the agreement
The legal consequence of § 305c Abs. 1 BGB is that a surprising clause does not become part of the agreement.
The OLG therefore did not have to decide whether the co-liability clause might also have failed the substantive review of standard terms and conditions on other grounds. The decisive factor was that, due to its surprising nature, the clause had not been validly incorporated into the lease transfer agreement.
In the absence of a valid contractual basis, the lessor could therefore not hold the outgoing lessee liable for the new lessee’s payment arrears.
Legal significance and conclusion
The judgment of the OLG Frankfurt am Main underscores the importance of protection against surprising terms pursuant to § 305c Abs. 1 BGB when standard terms and conditions are used in lease transfer agreements.
From the outgoing lessee’s perspective, the fundamental purpose of a transfer of contract is to withdraw from the existing contractual relationship and transfer the associated obligations to the new lessee.
If the outgoing lessee is nevertheless to remain liable for the new lessee’s obligations despite the transfer of the agreement, this far-reaching legal consequence must be sufficiently apparent to them.
A co-liability clause contained merely in the body text of the standard terms and conditions is insufficient for this purpose, at least where neither the designation nor the other aspects of the agreement’s layout indicate continuing liability.
For leasing companies, the decision means that they must exercise particular care when drafting transfer agreements. If the outgoing lessee is to remain jointly liable, this must be stated clearly and unambiguously. Visual emphasis or spatial separation from the remaining contractual text may be crucial in this regard.
For outgoing lessees, the judgment clarifies that they are not automatically required to assume that they will remain liable for their successor’s obligations following a transfer of contract. Instead, the decisive factors are
-
whether a corresponding liability provision was validly agreed
-
and whether, taking account of the specific layout of the agreement, it satisfies the requirements of § 305c Abs. 1 BGB.
The judgment therefore strengthens the protection of contracting parties against surprising liability provisions concealed in contractual forms.
MTR Legal advises on clauses in lease agreements and other matters of contract law. Further information is available under Legal advice on contract law.