Menu

Tolerated Breaches by a Managing Director Do Not Justify Summary Dismissal

Published on November 17, 2026

Breaches of duty by a managing director that have long been known and tolerated by the employer do not automatically justify extraordinary dismissal with immediate effect. This was held by the Landgericht Darmstadt (Darmstadt Regional Court) in its judgment of 21 September 2026 (Az. 18 O 7/22, case no. 18 O 7/22). The proceedings also concerned a post-contractual non-compete clause and the corresponding non-compete compensation.

Breaches of duty by the managing director

The claimant, who was already over 60 years old at the time of the dispute, had been employed by the defendant since 1996. In February 2006, he was appointed managing director.

The service agreement concluded between the parties contained various provisions governing the managing director’s rights and obligations. These included, in particular:

  • A limitation of liability to intentional conduct and gross negligence.

  • Performance-related remuneration.

  • A post-contractual non-compete clause.

  • An entitlement to non-compete compensation for the duration of the non-compete period.

During the parties’ many years of working together, the managing director committed breaches of duty. The defendant had been aware of these for an extended period and had effectively tolerated them.

Nevertheless, on 13 November 2019, the company ultimately terminated the service relationship extraordinarily and with immediate effect. The post-contractual non-compete clause was also in dispute: the defendant did not declare its waiver until after the service relationship had ended.

By letter dated 18 November 2019, the managing director challenged the extraordinary dismissal and asserted, among other things, claims relating to the non-compete compensation.

Judgment of the LG Darmstadt

The LG Darmstadt (Landgericht Darmstadt) held that the extraordinary dismissal was invalid. Consequently, it upheld the managing director’s claim for non-compete compensation in return for complying with the post-contractual non-compete clause.

In the court’s view, breaches of duty that had been known to the company for years and effectively tolerated by it do not automatically justify extraordinary dismissal under § 626 Abs. 1 BGB (German Civil Code). The breach of duty alone therefore does not automatically constitute good cause for the immediate termination of the service relationship.

Instead, the decisive issue is whether, taking all the circumstances of the individual case into account, the company can reasonably be expected to continue the service relationship until the expiry of the ordinary notice period. This requires an overall assessment that is not limited to establishing the breach of duty.

The mere fact that a managing director has breached his contractual obligations is not sufficient. How the company dealt with the breaches of duty in question in the past is also relevant. If the company was aware of them for an extended period without taking appropriate action, this must be taken into account when assessing whether it can reasonably be expected to continue the service relationship.

Entitlement to non-compete compensation despite waiver

The court also considered the post-contractual non-compete clause and the associated non-compete compensation.

The service agreement stipulated that the company could waive the post-contractual non-compete clause only before the service relationship ended. However, the defendant did not declare the waiver until after the agreement had ended.

In the Landgericht’s view, this subsequent declaration could no longer extinguish the managing director’s entitlement to non-compete compensation. The contractually agreed time limit on the right of waiver was decisive.

Good cause for extraordinary dismissal

Under § 626 Abs. 1 BGB, extraordinary dismissal requires good cause. Whether good cause exists must be determined by comprehensively weighing the interests of both parties.

In addition, the time limit under § 626 Abs. 2 BGB must be observed: extraordinary dismissal may be declared only within two weeks of acquiring knowledge of the relevant facts. This point may be decisive, particularly where breaches of duty have been known and tolerated for years, because the period may already have begun when the relevant facts first became known.

It must be examined whether, taking into account all the circumstances of the individual case and weighing the interests of both parties, the terminating party can reasonably be expected to continue the contractual relationship until the expiry of the ordinary notice period. The decisive factor is therefore an overall assessment that considers both the circumstances of the alleged breaches of duty and the respective interests of the contracting parties.

In this respect, the Landgericht Darmstadt placed particular emphasis on the company’s long-standing treatment of the alleged breaches of duty. This treatment was relevant to the assessment of whether it was still reasonable to continue the contractual relationship until the expiry of the ordinary notice period.

If a company is aware of certain conduct over an extended period and effectively tolerates it, it cannot subsequently rely on the same circumstances without further justification to support the immediate termination of the service relationship. In particular, such tolerance may affect the assessment of whether it is still reasonable to continue the service relationship.

The previous treatment of the breaches of duty is therefore a material element of the required balancing of interests. Consideration must be given to how the company previously responded to the known conduct.

Tolerated breaches of duty do not preclude extraordinary dismissal as a matter of principle. The individual circumstances are decisive. New or particularly serious breaches of duty may therefore warrant a different assessment.

Waiver of the non-compete clause only before the end of the agreement

With regard to the non-compete compensation, the court likewise relied on the specific contractual agreement. The parties had expressly stipulated that the post-contractual non-compete clause could be waived only before the service relationship ended.

The agreed deadline was decisive. The company did not declare the waiver until after the agreement had ended and therefore could no longer extinguish its pre-existing obligation to pay non-compete compensation.

The decision thus highlights the importance of clear contractual provisions governing the waiver of post-contractual non-compete clauses.

From an economic perspective, the contractually defined time limit on the right of waiver determines whether the company can release itself from its payment obligation or owes non-compete compensation for the entire duration of the non-compete period. If the waiver is declared only after the agreement has ended—as in the case before the LG Darmstadt—the obligation to pay compensation remains in place and, over a non-compete period lasting several years, may amount to a substantial sum based on the managing director’s annual remuneration. As the amount in dispute in court proceedings is calculated by reference to these recurring payments, the obligation to pay compensation also entails a corresponding cost risk. An early decision on the waiver that complies with the contractual deadline is therefore important not only from a legal but also from a financial planning perspective.

However, the decision must be viewed in the context of the case law of the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice), according to which a managing director—unlike employees under §§ 74 ff. HGB (German Commercial Code)—does not necessarily have to be promised compensation for a post-contractual non-compete clause. For members of corporate bodies, the entitlement to non-compete compensation is generally based on a contractual undertaking, meaning that the scope of the Darmstadt judgment is determined by the specific contractual arrangements. 

This freedom of contract also means that non-compete compensation may be made subject to conditions. For example, a managing director’s service agreement may validly stipulate that the entitlement to non-compete compensation lapses retroactively if the managing director breaches the post-contractual non-compete clause. If there is no such forfeiture clause, the entitlement to compensation generally remains in place. It is therefore advisable to include express provisions on forfeiture and repayment when the agreement is concluded.

Careful drafting is also required with regard to the amount of compensation and the offsetting of other income. Since §§ 74 ff. HGB do not apply directly to members of corporate bodies, the basis of calculation and method of payment are governed by the contractual undertaking; likewise, other income is offset in accordance with § 74c HGB only if this has been expressly agreed in the case of managing directors. It should also be made clear that garden leave before the agreement ends does not shorten the term of the post-contractual non-compete clause or, consequently, the non-compete period, as garden leave affects only the obligation to perform services under the ongoing service relationship.

Practical significance of the decision

The judgment of the LG Darmstadt is particularly relevant to companies and managing directors.

For companies: Where managing directors commit breaches of duty, prompt review and documentation are of considerable importance. If certain conduct is tolerated for years, this may make it significantly more difficult to rely on the same circumstances subsequently as grounds for dismissal. The company’s previous response may therefore influence the assessment of whether it can reasonably be expected to continue the contractual relationship until the expiry of the ordinary notice period.

For managing directors: The decision makes clear that extraordinary dismissal cannot be justified solely by the existence of breaches of duty. Instead, the relevant circumstances must be assessed. When balancing the interests involved, consideration must also be given to how the company responded to the conduct in question in the past and whether it tolerated that conduct for an extended period.

For contract drafting: In the case of post-contractual non-compete clauses, it is particularly important to specify the deadline for a waiver and the consequences of such a waiver for non-compete compensation. Non-compete compensation provides financial compensation for the managing director remaining bound by the agreed non-compete clause after the contractual relationship has ended. Precise contractual provisions can therefore determine the period within which a waiver may be declared and its effects on the entitlement to compensation.

With regard to the dismissal, the company’s previous treatment of the breaches of duty was decisive. With regard to the non-compete clause, however, the contractually stipulated deadline for the waiver was decisive.

MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte advises companies, management board members, corporate bodies and investors on matters of corporate law and in contentious shareholder situations. Further information is available at Corporate Law Advice.

More articles

OLG Frankfurt: Mithaftung bei Leasingübernahme unwirksam – Foto: Antoni Shkraba / Pexels

Contract Law

OLG Frankfurt: Co-Liability in Lease Transfers Invalid

November 17, 2026

EU-Kommission genehmigt Übernahme der Commerzbank – Foto: Nadine Bliedung / Pexels

Competition Law

European Commission Approves Commerzbank Takeover

November 17, 2026

Vorsteuerabzug für Reisekosten zur Betriebsveranstaltung – Foto: Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels

Tax Law

Input VAT Deduction for Travel Costs to a Company Event

November 17, 2026

Book a callback

Available now16:33

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220