Menu

Trade Tax Provision Increases Disposal Gain

Published on November 21, 2026

Gewerbesteuerrückstellung erhöht Veräußerungsgewinn – Foto: Gustavo Fring / Pexels

The Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) has clarified the tax treatment of a trade tax provision upon the sale of an interest in a partnership. According to the judgment, the provision reduces the disposing partner’s tax capital account on a pro rata basis, thereby increasing the partner’s disposal gain. This also applies insofar as the trade tax is attributable to the disposal of the interest (BFH, judgment of 8 October 2026 – IV R 4/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.081026.IVR4.25.0).

Disposal of an Interest in a GbR

In the year in dispute, 2017, the claimant, a GmbH (German limited liability company), held a 19 percent interest in a commercially active GbR (German civil-law partnership). The other partners were B-GmbH and D-GmbH. The claimant sold its partnership interest to D-GmbH.

Provisions of the Withdrawal Agreement

Under the agreement entered into on 21 December 2017, the claimant sold its interest, including the capital account and the entitlement to profits, with effect as of the end of 31 December 2017. The partnership’s results were to accrue entirely to the purchaser. In addition to the partnership interest, several receivables were transferred.

The agreement also contained various indemnification provisions. Among other things, the purchaser indemnified the claimant against rent claims of the GbR amounting to EUR 5,658.

Findings of the Finanzamt

The Finanzamt (German tax office) initially determined a current loss at partnership level for the GbR and a disposal gain for the claimant. At the same time, it made a separate and uniform determination for 2017 under § 35 Abs. 2 EStG (section 35(2) of the German Income Tax Act). In accordance with its interest, 19 percent of the partnership’s trade tax base amount was allocated to the claimant.

In the objection proceedings, the claimant raised several objections. These concerned in particular:

  • It disputed the amount of B-GmbH’s special business income.
  • It requested that the GbR’s rent claim against it amounting to EUR 5,658 be recognised and that its disposal gain be increased accordingly.
  • It took the view that the share of the trade tax base amount should be allocated to the purchaser due to the timing of the transfer.
  • It objected to the pro rata recognition of the trade tax provision of EUR 12,951.54 when determining its disposal gain.
  • It asserted that the extended trade tax reduction under § 9 Nr. 1 Satz 2 GewStG (section 9 no. 1 sentence 2 of the German Trade Tax Act) was no longer available.

The Finanzamt upheld the objection with regard to the special business income, the rent claim and the extended trade tax reduction. However, it rejected the objections concerning the allocation of the trade tax base amount and the trade tax provision.

Disposal Gain of EUR 461,905.91

During the subsequent court proceedings, the Finanzamt amended the determination notice. Due to the rent claim, it reduced the GbR’s current loss at partnership level by EUR 5,658 to EUR 72,072.62. It allocated EUR 13,693.80 of this amount to the claimant.

The Finanzamt continued to determine the claimant’s disposal gain at EUR 461,905.91. The calculation was based on a tax capital account of EUR 14,474.42. This amount reflected the trade tax provision of EUR 12,951.54 attributable to the claimant.

Decision of the Sächsisches Finanzgericht

The Sächsisches Finanzgericht (Saxony Fiscal Court) dismissed the action. According to its interpretation of the agreement, there had been no change of partners during the year. The purchaser had not become the holder of the interest until midnight at the turn of the year.

The Finanzgericht also took into account that the claimant had participated in the 2017 annual result in accordance with its interest. The other parties therefore had no reason to understand the agreement as meaning that the claimant would receive the income attributable to it for the year but would not bear the corresponding share of the trade tax. The GbR’s determination return for 2017 also allocated the pro rata trade tax base amount to the claimant.

Appeal on Points of Law Before the Bundesfinanzhof

In its appeal on points of law, the claimant alleged breaches of procedural and substantive law. It requested that no share of the trade tax base amount be determined for it and that the disposal gain be reduced by EUR 12,951.54 to EUR 448,954.37.

The Claimant’s Arguments

The claimant submitted that it had withdrawn from the GbR before the trade tax arose under § 18 GewStG (section 18 of the German Trade Tax Act). Although the GbR was required to recognise a provision for the anticipated trade tax expense for the 2017 financial year, the claimant maintained that the provision could be allocated only to those partners holding an interest at the end of the assessment period, in accordance with the general profit allocation ratio.

As it was no longer a partner on the relevant balance sheet date, the pro rata provision could not reduce its capital account. In the alternative, it alleged a violation of its right to be heard.

Court Order Partially Became a Judgment

The Bundesfinanzhof had initially dismissed the appeal on points of law as unfounded by court order dated 10 June 2026. With regard to the determination under § 35 Abs. 2 EStG, it considered the action inadmissible due to a lack of standing. The allocation of a share of the trade tax base amount had no adverse effect on the claimant because a GmbH is not subject to income tax and therefore cannot claim a tax reduction under § 35 EStG (section 35 of the German Income Tax Act).

Limited Request for an Oral Hearing

The claimant subsequently requested an oral hearing. In the reasons for its request, it initially stated expressly that it agreed with the Bundesfinanzhof’s view regarding the determination under § 35 Abs. 2 EStG and raised no objections in this respect. Only after the relevant one-month period had expired did it request that this part of the reasoning also be reconsidered.

Based on its unambiguous wording, the Bundesfinanzhof construed the request filed within the prescribed period as being limited to the profit determination notice. The determination under § 35 Abs. 2 EStG constituted a severable subject matter of the action. With regard to this subject matter, which was not covered by the request, the court order therefore took effect as a judgment pursuant to § 90a Abs. 3 Halbsatz 1 FGO (section 90a(3), first half-sentence, of the German Fiscal Court Code).

The extension declared after expiry of the period could not alter this. In the court’s view, the subsequently cited amended corporation tax assessment notice also failed to establish any comprehensible connection either with the GbR’s determination return or with the pro rata allocation of the trade tax base amount.

Trade Tax Provision Reduces the Capital Account

The sole subject matter of the remaining appeal proceedings was therefore the amount of the disposal gain determined in the profit determination notice. The appeal was unsuccessful in this respect.

Determination Subject to a Separate Challenge

A profit determination notice may contain several independent determinations, each of which may be challenged separately and may become final. These include the determination of whether a disposal gain was realised. This must be distinguished from the amount of the gain and its classification as extraordinary income.

The claimant did not dispute that it had realised a disposal gain in 2017. Its claim was directed exclusively against the amount of that gain. To this extent, its action was admissible because this determination concerned it personally.

Determination Under § 16 EStG

Under § 16 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 EStG (section 16(1), sentence 1, no. 2 of the German Income Tax Act), gains from the disposal of a partner’s entire interest constitute income from trade or business. Pursuant to § 16 Abs. 2 Satz 1 EStG, the disposal gain is the amount by which the disposal price, after deduction of the disposal costs, exceeds the value of the interest in the business assets.

The decisive factor is therefore the difference between the consideration granted in connection with the withdrawal and the tax capital account. Pursuant to § 16 Abs. 2 Satz 2 EStG, its value must be determined as at the time of withdrawal in accordance with § 4 Abs. 1 or § 5 EStG (sections 4(1) or 5 of the German Income Tax Act).

Even where a disposal takes place during the financial year, the carrying amount of the interest must be determined as at the date of disposal in accordance with the general principles of tax accounting. If no corresponding closing balance sheet exists, the value must be calculated and, where necessary, estimated. A share of profit accrued up to the date of disposal remains current income of the disposing partner.

Provision Indirectly Increases the Disposal Gain

The tax capital account is affected by the share of current profit or loss. Consequently, when determining it, all liabilities and provisions required to be recognised in the tax balance sheet must be taken into account on a pro rata basis.

According to the decision, this also applies to a trade tax provision and to the portion attributable to a gain from the disposal of a partnership interest. The provision reduces the departing partner’s tax capital account on a pro rata basis. Because a lower capital account is deducted from the disposal price, the taxable disposal gain increases accordingly.

Inclusion of Trade Tax Attributable to the Sale

This treatment may result in the provision reducing the capital account while simultaneously increasing the trade tax base for the disposal gain. In the Bundesfinanzhof’s view, this relationship does not justify a different assessment either.

§ 7 Satz 2 Nr. 2 GewStG (section 7, sentence 2, no. 2 of the German Trade Tax Act) provides that gains from the disposal of a partnership interest form part of the partnership’s trade income unless they are attributable to a natural person holding a direct interest as a partner. This allocation requires the disposal gain to arise before the partner’s withdrawal. It is therefore attributable to the period before the change of entrepreneur and to the trade income accrued up to that point.

Consequently, at the time of withdrawal, the departing partner’s capital account must still be reduced by that partner’s share of the trade tax provision attributable to the disposal gain. The fact that, pursuant to § 18 GewStG, the trade tax does not arise until the end of the assessment period does not alter this conclusion.

Tax Deduction Prohibition Without Balance-Sheet Effect

Nor does § 4 Abs. 5b EStG (section 4(5b) of the German Income Tax Act) preclude this treatment. The provision excludes the deduction of trade tax as a business expense. The trade tax initially recognised in determining the profit is therefore added back outside the balance sheet.

Because this adjustment is made off balance sheet, it does not alter the trade tax provision to be recognised in the tax balance sheet. The provision must therefore continue to be taken into account when determining the capital account.

Calculation in the Case at Hand

The GbR’s total trade tax provision amounted to EUR 68,166. Based on the 19 percent interest, EUR 12,951.54 was attributable to the claimant. This amount reduced its tax capital account.

As at 31 December 2017, the capital account therefore amounted to EUR 14,474.42. After deducting this amount from the disposal price of EUR 476,380.33, the disposal gain amounted to EUR 461,905.91. The Finanzamt’s determination was therefore not open to objection.

No Different Assessment Under Earlier Case Law

The claimant relied on an earlier judgment of the Bundesfinanzhof concerning a partner’s withdrawal during the year. However, the statements made in that judgment concerned § 35 EStG and the standardised allocation formula stipulated for the purposes of that provision.

The statement that the trade tax expense is generally borne by the partners holding an interest at the end of the assessment period in accordance with the profit allocation ratio under the partnership agreement related to the allocation of the trade tax base amount under § 35 EStG. It did not answer the question relevant to the present proceedings of how a trade tax provision is to be treated when calculating the disposal gain.

The Bundesfinanzhof therefore found no contradiction between the decisions. They concern different areas of tax law.

Violation of the Right to Be Heard Did Not Affect the Outcome

The claimant had also objected that the Finanzgericht had failed to consider its submissions regarding the actual implementation of the withdrawal agreement. These included the purchaser’s recognition of the acquired interest as an asset as at 31 December 2017 and the contractual provision under which the partnership’s results were to accrue entirely to the purchaser.

The Bundesfinanzhof considered this complaint to be well founded on the merits. Nevertheless, the violation did not result in the judgment of the Finanzgericht being set aside. Even if the omitted submissions had been considered in full, no different decision would have been possible under the applicable tax principles.

The statutory presumption under § 119 Nr. 3 FGO (section 119 no. 3 of the German Fiscal Court Code) does not apply where the violation of the right to be heard concerns only individual findings or aspects that, from the perspective of the court hearing the appeal on points of law, are not decisive for the outcome under any legal analysis. The appeal on points of law was therefore dismissed in its entirety as unfounded.

Significance for the Tax Treatment of Disposals of Interests

The judgment makes clear that the determination of the disposal gain and the allocation of a trade tax base amount under § 35 EStG must be treated separately. A trade tax provision may reduce the disposing partner’s tax capital account on a pro rata basis even if it is attributable to the sale of that partner’s interest. The resulting reduction in the capital account increases the disposal gain accordingly.

The claimant was ordered to bear the costs of the appeal proceedings. The out-of-court costs of the GbR’s joined universal successor were not recoverable because it had neither filed its own substantive application nor materially advanced the proceedings. MTR Legal advises companies, investors and high-net-worth individuals on legal issues concerning the taxation of partnership interests and the classification of corresponding determination notices as part of its tax law advisory services.

Sources

More articles

BFH zur Betriebsaufspaltung bei Photovoltaikanlagen – Foto: Vladimir Srajber / Pexels

Tax Law

BFH on Business Splitting for Photovoltaic Systems

November 20, 2026

BFH: Geschätzte Betriebsausgaben begründen keine Vorsteuer – Foto: Erik Mclean auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH: Estimated Business Expenses Do Not Justify Input VAT Deduction

November 20, 2026

BFH zur gewinnneutralen Berichtigung der Eröffnungsbilanz – Foto: Usman Malik auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH on Tax-Neutral Correction of Opening Balance Sheets

November 20, 2026

Book a callback

Not availableAvailable again Monday from 07:00

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220