Menu

BFH on Tax-Neutral Correction of Opening Balance Sheets

Published on November 20, 2026

By BFH, Beschluss vom 29. September 2026 – X B 64, 65/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:B.290926.XB64.25.0 (Federal Fiscal Court, order of 29 September 2026 – case nos. X B 64, 65/25), the Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) joined the proceedings for a joint decision, set aside two judgments of the Finanzgericht Nürnberg (Nuremberg Fiscal Court) and remitted the cases for a new hearing and decision. In the BFH’s view, the decision concerning the correction of the balance sheet was based on a violation of the right to be heard. The Fiscal Court had failed to correctly apprehend the material content of a subsequently filed written submission and had therefore improperly exercised its discretion regarding the reopening of the oral hearing.

Dispute over balance sheet correction and loan interest

Lease of the hotel property and taking out of loans

The claimant’s mother owned a hotel property that she initially leased commercially to a Kommanditgesellschaft (German limited partnership). The property formed part of her special business assets. In 2007, a foreign savings bank granted loans totalling EUR 2.7 million to the limited partnership and to an entity designated as “Firma Sonderbetriebsvermögen”. The hotel property was encumbered with a land charge as security.

From 2010, the hotel was leased to an Unternehmergesellschaft (German entrepreneurial company). The resulting income was treated as income from letting and leasing. Insolvency proceedings concerning the assets of the mother and the limited partnership had been ongoing since 2010. Following insolvency proceedings in the United Kingdom, the mother obtained a discharge from residual debt in 2011.

After this lease ended in 2015, the mother leased the hotel to another Unternehmergesellschaft, of which she was the indirect sole shareholder. It was common ground between the parties that this now constituted a Betriebsaufspaltung (business split) and that commercial income was once again generated.

Accounting treatment of the liabilities

The opening balance sheet for 2015 reported liabilities of EUR 3 million to the foreign savings bank. According to counsel, this amount comprised the principal claim and interest that had not been extinguished under foreign law. As at 31 December 2017, liabilities to banks of EUR 3.6 million were recognised in the balance sheet.

The mother died on 15 September 2017. The claimant continued her commercial activity and reported liabilities to banks of EUR 3.7 million as at 31 December 2018. The income statement included interest expenses of EUR 210,000.

The Finanzamt (German tax office) disallowed these interest expenses. During the objection proceedings, it also derecognised the liabilities of EUR 3.7 million to the savings bank, thereby increasing taxable profit. In its view, the loan claims had no longer been enforceable since the discharge from residual debt and should have been derecognised in 2011 with a corresponding increase in profit.

In the Tax Office’s view, the correction was to be made in the first year that remained procedurally open to amendment. The intervening change in legal ownership did not alter this because the liability was a business liability and the relevant point of reference was therefore the business itself.

Differing views of the parties

The claimant’s position

The claimant disputed the assumption that restructuring income had arisen in 2011. Following the discharge from residual debt, his mother had generated income from letting and leasing. The liability had therefore formed part of her private assets.

Moreover, the discharge from residual debt had not extinguished the encumbrance in rem over the hotel property. This continuing encumbrance had to be recognised in the balance sheet. According to his submissions, the interest expenses claimed had served to prevent enforcement against the property.

The Tax Office’s position

The Tax Office took the view that the loan had formed part of the business assets from the outset and had therefore remained within the tax net. There was no evidence of a cessation of the business or of any act of withdrawal from the business assets.

In any event, business assets had existed since the business split arose in 2015. The accounting treatment at that time had therefore been incorrect. In addition, the Tax Office considered that there was insufficient reliable documentation regarding the interest expenses claimed.

Written submission filed after the oral hearing

Discharge of the land charge

The Fiscal Court held an oral hearing in both proceedings on 22 May 2025. Evidence was submitted showing that the land charge had been discharged in 2019 by a payment of EUR 1.6 million to the foreign savings bank. This amount was financed by another bank.

The minutes of the hearing recorded that the factual and legal issues had been discussed. They did not record any guidance from the Fiscal Court or any statements by the parties as to which accounting error could be corrected for which year and with what effect on profit.

Significance of the 2015 opening balance sheet

On 25 May 2025, counsel filed a further written submission. She stated that the termination of the previous lease as at 30 June 2010 had resulted in a cessation of the business under § 16 Abs. 3 EStG (German Income Tax Act) and the realisation of hidden reserves. The property had subsequently formed part of the mother’s private assets. Commercial income had only been generated again as a result of the renewed business split from 1 January 2015.

The liability had been contributed to the business together with the property. Its recognition as a liability had been justified by the savings bank’s right of enforcement in rem. Counsel did not consider it decisive whether it should have been recognised as a liability or as a provision.

The central point of the subsequent submission was that recognition in the opening balance sheet had no effect on profit. As the liability had been contributed when the commercial business commenced on 1 January 2015, recognising it as a liability had not reduced profit. According to the claimant’s submissions, any subsequent correction could therefore likewise not increase profit to that extent.

Partial success before the Fiscal Court

The Fiscal Court did not reopen the oral hearing and partially upheld the actions. It considered the derecognition of the liability to be correct but, in return, required a provision of EUR 1.6 million to be recognised for an uncertain obligation in rem. It disallowed the interest expenses claimed due to a lack of evidence.

In the Fiscal Court’s view, the discharge from residual debt had transformed the loan liabilities into unenforceable imperfect obligations. The accounting error had arisen in 2015 and had to be corrected in 2018, the first year that remained open.

The court nevertheless considered a provision necessary because the land charge had continued to exist as an encumbrance in rem. From the redemption amount of EUR 1.6 million paid in 2019, it inferred that enforcement might have occurred as at 31 December 2018.

The Fiscal Court did not consider it necessary to reopen the oral hearing. It held that the subsequently filed written submission had essentially repeated arguments already known and had not contained any new facts material to the decision.

BFH criticises treatment of the balance sheet correction

Entries in an opening balance sheet are tax-neutral

The BFH clarified that the Fiscal Court’s reasoning regarding the profit-increasing balance sheet correction was incompatible with its settled case law. The Fiscal Court had correctly assumed that the potential accounting error arising from recognition of the liability had occurred in 2015. It had also correctly proceeded on the basis that a correction can affect profit only if the original error had already affected profit.

However, according to the BFH order, the subsequent conclusion that the liability had to be derecognised with a corresponding increase in profit was incorrect. Entries in an opening balance sheet are tax-neutral. Their correction must therefore likewise be tax-neutral.

Only subsequent accounting changes based on the original entry can affect profit. This may be the case, for example, with depreciation or amounts recognised as liabilities through profit or loss in subsequent years.

No correction of a potential error from 2011

At the same time, the BFH confirmed that the Fiscal Court had been right not to follow the Tax Office’s original approach. An amendment of the 2018 balance sheet could not correct a potential error from 2011.

During the intervening lease to the first Unternehmergesellschaft, the mother had generated income from letting and leasing. This income was not determined by comparing business assets. If a profit arising from the cessation of the business had been treated incorrectly upon the transition from commercial to private leasing, this could not be remedied by means of a subsequent balance sheet correction due to the absence of balance sheet continuity.

According to the BFH, nor had there been a lease of the entire business without a cessation of the business. The mother had merely transferred the hotel previously leased to the limited partnership to an Unternehmergesellschaft. The BFH regarded this as a change of tenant rather than a lease of the existing commercial leasing business.

Improper exercise of discretion concerning reopening

Court must disclose material considerations

Under § 93 Abs. 3 Satz 2 FGO (German Fiscal Court Code), a Fiscal Court may reopen an oral hearing that has already been closed. Whether it does so is generally a matter for its discretion.

If a written submission is received after the close of the oral hearing, the court must examine of its own motion whether the hearing should be reopened. According to the BFH, the following requirements apply in particular:

  • The court must weigh the factors for and against reopening the hearing.
  • The principal considerations must be apparent from the decision.
  • The exercise of discretion must be based on a correct and complete understanding of the facts.
  • Consideration must be given, among other things, to whether the late submission resulted from an omission by the party or a failure by the court.
  • It may also be relevant whether an evidently incorrect decision would otherwise be likely without reopening the hearing.

If the decision is based on an incorrect factual basis, this constitutes an error in the exercise of discretion. It may also amount to a procedural defect under § 115 Abs. 2 Nr. 3 FGO (German Fiscal Court Code).

Central content of the written submission was disregarded

In the BFH’s view, the Fiscal Court had failed to correctly apprehend the central point of the written submission of 25 May 2025. The essential argument was that recognition of the liability in the opening balance sheet as at 1 January 2015 had been tax-neutral. The claimant inferred from this that the correction in 2018, the first year remaining open, likewise had to be tax-neutral to that extent.

This point had neither been included in the earlier written submissions nor could it be established that it had already been raised during the oral hearing. The minutes contained no information in this regard. Nor did the grounds for the decision indicate that the Fiscal Court had actually considered this argument.

The reasoning that the subsequently filed written submission had merely repeated matters already known therefore did not justify refusing to reopen the hearing. The Fiscal Court had based its discretionary decision on a materially incomplete and therefore incorrect basis.

No mandatory refusal to reopen the hearing

The BFH rejected the proposition that the court’s discretion had been reduced to the extent that refusing to reopen the hearing was the only lawful decision. The written submission was neither devoid of content nor manifestly limited to repetition.

Nor was there any indication of a serious breach of the duties of cooperation. Until the oral hearing, the proceedings had focused on a different issue. The Tax Office had based its decision primarily on the discharge from residual debt in 2011 and the failure at that time to derecognise the liability with a corresponding increase in profit.

The BFH left open whether the Fiscal Court itself would necessarily have been required to reopen the hearing. The decisive point was that the discretionary decision actually made was defective and that the Fiscal Court judgments could have been based on that defect.

Guidance for the further proceedings

Differentiation according to the effect on profit

For the new hearing, the BFH clarified how the loan liability is to be treated in principle:

  • To the extent that the liability had already been recognised tax-neutrally in the opening balance sheet as at 1 January 2015 and still existed at the beginning of 2018, it must be derecognised tax-neutrally in the opening balance sheet as at 1 January 2018.
  • To the extent that the liabilities recognised at the end of 2018 were based on amounts recognised as liabilities through profit or loss in the years from 2015 to 2017, any correction would, by contrast, have to affect profit.

The Fiscal Court had not yet established the extent to which the liabilities reported at the beginning of 2018 were attributable to the original entry in the 2015 opening balance sheet. The BFH was therefore unable to issue a final decision.

Deductibility of interest payments as business expenses remains unresolved

The treatment of the interest payments claimed likewise remains unresolved. According to the BFH, no findings have yet been made as to whether payments were actually made, the amount of those payments and the purpose they served.

If payments were made to avert enforcement measures based on the security interests over the hotel property, it must still be examined whether they constituted expenses incurred for business purposes within the meaning of § 4 Abs. 4 EStG (German Income Tax Act). The BFH was no longer required to decide in the appeal proceedings whether the Fiscal Court had also committed a procedural error in connection with the interest expenses.

Fiscal Court must decide again

The BFH set aside both judgments and remitted the proceedings to the Finanzgericht Nürnberg under § 116 Abs. 6 FGO (German Fiscal Court Code). The Fiscal Court must make the outstanding findings of fact and decide again on the balance sheet correction and the interest expenses claimed. The decision on the costs of the appeal proceedings was also assigned to the Fiscal Court.

The order illustrates that the incorrect nature of a balance sheet item is not the sole determining factor in a balance sheet correction. It is equally decisive whether the original recognition of that item had already affected profit. Companies, investors and high-net-worth private individuals can obtain guidance from MTR Legal on the tax treatment of opening balance sheets, business liabilities and Fiscal Court proceedings as part of its tax law advisory services.

Sources

More articles

StaRUG erfasst Bürgschaften von Geschäftsführern nicht – Foto: Matheus Lara / Pexels

Insolvency Law

StaRUG Does Not Cover Guarantees by Managing Directors

November 20, 2026

BFH begrenzt Versagung des Vorsteuerabzugs – Foto: Zlaťáky.cz auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH Limits Denial of Input VAT Deduction

November 20, 2026

Urheberrecht: LG Köln stärkt Schutz vor Video-Uploads – Foto: Mizuno K / Pexels

Copyright Law

Copyright: LG Köln strengthens protection against video uploads

November 20, 2026

Book a callback

Available now16:17

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220