Menu

BFH: Estimated Business Expenses Do Not Justify Input VAT Deduction

Published on November 20, 2026

BFH: Geschätzte Betriebsausgaben begründen keine Vorsteuer – Foto: Erik Mclean auf Unsplash

In its judgment of 3 September 2026 – V R 33/25 (case no.), ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.030926.VR33.25.0, the Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) ruled that business expenses estimated solely for income tax purposes do not, in themselves, justify an input VAT deduction. All requirements under § 15(1), sentence 1, no. 1 UStG (German VAT Act) must still be examined. At the same time, the BFH objected to the Finanzgericht’s assessment concerning the purchase of a sports car that was resold shortly thereafter. Following the appeals on points of law lodged by the Finanzamt and the claimant, the judgment of the Hessisches Finanzgericht (Hessian Fiscal Court) was set aside and the case remitted for a new hearing and decision.

Marketing, motor racing and high-end vehicles

The claimant’s activities

The claimant is a Gesellschaft bürgerlichen Rechts (GbR, civil-law partnership) established in 2010. Its partners were two brothers who operated a joint medical practice alongside a clinic and held interests in other partnerships and legal entities. Between 2010 and 2013, the claimant operated a marketing and events agency.

Its activities included advertising and organisational services for the clinic. It also organised marketing events in connection with motor racing events. Most of its revenue came from marketing and consultancy services provided to companies belonging to the two partners and to the sole proprietorship of one partner’s life partner. The claimant also received payments from sponsors that had business ties to the joint medical practice or personal ties to the partners. It did not earn any prize money from racing activities in the years at issue.

Findings of the tax investigation

During a tax investigation, the tax authorities found that a substantial portion of the input VAT claimed related to several high-end sports cars, a luxury vehicle and racing cars. The racing cars were used to compete in X-Cup races.

According to the investigation findings, which the claimant did not dispute, the sports cars that were not used for racing and the luxury vehicle were used exclusively for private purposes. By contrast, the racing cars displayed mandatory stickers, advertising for the clinic and the sponsors’ names. Their logos also appeared on the team jackets.

In July 2011, the claimant also purchased a sports car that could be used as a racing car in motor racing. The vehicle was not registered for use on public roads and was resold as early as August 2011.

Finanzamt limited the input VAT deduction

Expenses for privately used vehicles and motor racing

The auditors considered the input VAT on the acquisition and running costs of the privately used sports cars and the luxury vehicle to be non-deductible under § 15(1a) UStG in conjunction with § 12 no. 1 EStG (German Income Tax Act). In their assessment, these constituted private living expenses.

The auditors also denied the input VAT deduction for the racing cars and other motor-racing-related expenses, insofar as the costs were not already attributable to private purposes. In doing so, they relied on § 15(1a) UStG in conjunction with § 4(5), sentence 1, no. 4 EStG. Because the partners themselves participated in races, the auditors considered the expenses to have been incurred for private purposes to a not insignificant extent. They rejected their recognition under § 4(5), sentence 2, EStG because no profit-making intention had been demonstrated for the motor racing activities.

Consequently, the auditors ceased to include the previously declared turnover from the deemed supply arising from the private use of the sports cars. Instead, they denied the input VAT deduction insofar as the input transactions concerned the privately used vehicles, the luxury vehicle or motor racing.

Estimation of the remaining expenses

The tax authorities treated as deductible only those input VAT amounts that they allocated to the marketing and organisational services. To determine these amounts, they used the business expenses recognised in the profit calculation and made several adjustments:

  • The costs directly attributable to the vehicles were deducted from the business expenses.
  • General costs, including wages, entertainment, travel, IT and other expenses, were reduced proportionately insofar as the auditors allocated them to the privately used vehicles or the racing cars.
  • Expenses not subject to input VAT were deducted from the remaining marketing and organisational expenses.
  • Further amounts were estimated in the claimant’s favour for input transactions purportedly connected with the marketing services for the clinic.

The tax authorities recognised only the input VAT amounts determined in this manner. For income tax purposes, the auditors additionally reduced the profit by further estimated business expenses in the amount of the declared sponsorship revenue. However, this additional estimate for income tax purposes did not result in any further input VAT deduction.

The Finanzamt (Tax Office) amended the VAT assessments for the years 2010 to 2013 accordingly. The claimant’s administrative appeals were unsuccessful.

Partial success before the Finanzgericht

Additional input VAT on estimated business expenses

In the court proceedings, the claimant ultimately sought additional input VAT amounts on the business expenses that the Finanzamt had recognised only for income tax purposes in the amount of the sponsorship revenue. It also sought an input VAT deduction for 2011 in respect of the purchase of the sports car that had been resold in August of the same year. For 2013, it claimed input VAT on the acquisition of a sports car that was leased out that year.

During the proceedings, the claimant submitted a schedule of alleged input transactions. The Finanzgericht allowed its action in part. In its view, the input VAT deduction for input transactions connected with taxable sponsorship services could not be denied solely because the relevant business expenses had only been estimated for income tax purposes.

The Finanzgericht had no doubts regarding the amount claimed. It took into account that the claimant had accepted the Finanzamt’s uncontested reductions and had limited its claim to the business expenses recognised for income tax purposes. It also assumed that the corresponding invoices had been submitted and that no vehicle costs unrelated to sponsorship services were still being claimed.

Different treatment of the sports cars

The Finanzgericht granted the input VAT deduction for the sports car purchased in 2013 because the vehicle had been leased out in a taxable transaction. The Finanzamt did not challenge this part of the decision in the appeal proceedings.

The Finanzgericht reached a different conclusion regarding the sports car purchased in July 2011 and resold as early as August 2011. It found insufficient evidence that the vehicle had been intended for the business when it was purchased or that there had been a serious intention to lease it out. Nor did a profitable sale, in itself, establish business use.

According to the Finanzgericht’s assessment, the purchase, possession and sale were instead based on the partners’ personal preferences. In addition, it found that the deduction was barred under § 15(1a) UStG in conjunction with § 4(5), sentence 1, no. 4 EStG.

Appeals by the Finanzamt and the claimant

The Finanzamt’s objections

The Finanzamt challenged the additional input VAT deduction granted in respect of business expenses estimated solely for income tax purposes. It argued that the Finanzgericht had neither examined the requirements under § 15(1), sentence 1, no. 1 UStG nor applied § 15(1a) UStG.

According to the Finanzamt, the invoices submitted did not relate exclusively to sponsorship services such as displaying logos. Rather, some of the descriptions of services indicated a direct connection with racing events and support services in the X-Cup. The income tax treatment could have no binding effect for VAT purposes. The Finanzamt further argued that the claimant bore the burden of establishing the requirements for the input VAT deduction.

The claimant’s objections

The claimant challenged the denial of the input VAT deduction for the sports car held briefly in 2011. It argued that neither private use nor use in motor racing had been intended. Rather, it had been clear from the outset that the vehicle was to be resold at a profit after a short period.

By claiming the input VAT deduction, the vehicle had been allocated to the business assets. In the claimant’s view, its business activities also included ancillary and incidental transactions, without any requirement that these be carried out on a permanent basis. It also pointed out that it had sold other vehicles during the period at issue.

BFH requires individual examination of input transactions

Estimate for income tax purposes is insufficient

The BFH held that the Finanzamt’s appeal was well founded. The Finanzgericht had recognised the input VAT deduction arising from the business expenses estimated for income tax purposes without establishing the individual requirements under § 15(1), sentence 1, no. 1 UStG.

A taxable person may deduct as input VAT the tax legally due for supplies made by another taxable person if those supplies were made for their business and an invoice issued in accordance with §§ 14 and 14a UStG is available. Article 168(a) of the VAT Directive additionally requires the goods or services to be used for taxed transactions.

A person claiming an input VAT deduction must plead and prove the relevant facts. An estimate cannot replace the establishment of the substantive requirements for deduction. The recognition of estimated business expenses for income tax purposes has no independent significance for the VAT assessment.

Findings not made by the Finanzgericht

According to the BFH’s decision, the Finanzgericht had failed to establish, in particular,

  • which specific input transactions the claimant had received,
  • whether those transactions were directly connected with specific taxable output transactions or with its overall economic activity,
  • whether an invoice within the meaning of § 14 UStG existed for each individual input transaction and
  • to what extent the corresponding input VAT amounts had not already been recognised by the Finanzamt.

The general assumption that the claimant had submitted all invoices and was now seeking only input VAT on sponsorship-related expenses was insufficient. The schedule cited contained numerous input transactions and input VAT amounts that significantly exceeded the relief sought in the proceedings. Nor could limiting the application to the amount of the business expenses recognised for income tax purposes compensate for the missing findings.

Sports car resold after a short period must be reassessed

Overall circumstances of purchase and sale are decisive

The claimant’s appeal was also well founded. In the BFH’s view, the Finanzgericht had not taken into account all the circumstances surrounding the purchase and sale of the sports car acquired in 2011.

An economic activity may exist where a person takes active sales measures when selling and uses means comparable to those employed by a producer, trader or service provider. The number and scale of the transactions are not decisive in this regard. By contrast, the mere purchase and sale of an item is insufficient where the only possible remuneration consists of a profit on the sale.

If an item can be used both economically and privately, all circumstances relating to its actual or intended use must be taken into account. Although the Finanzgericht had considered the partners’ personal interest in high-end sports cars and the absence of evidence of an intention to lease out the vehicle, it had not examined whether the claimant had acted as a dealer when purchasing and selling it.

Possible vehicle trading activity

According to the BFH, it is also significant that only one month elapsed between the purchase and sale. In addition to its other activities, the claimant’s economic activity may therefore have included the short-term purchase and resale of high-priced vehicles.

The BFH also objected to the Finanzgericht’s alternative reasoning concerning the bar on deduction for unreasonable entertainment and prestige-related expenditure. The other sports cars had been held for several years and used privately. By contrast, the vehicle purchased in 2011 was resold after a short period and, according to the claimant’s submissions, which the Finanzamt did not dispute, was intended for neither private use nor racing. The Finanzgericht must include these differences in its overall assessment in the second round of proceedings.

Further examination by the Finanzgericht

Classification of the motor racing activities

The BFH was unable to issue a final decision because the necessary findings of fact were lacking. The Finanzgericht must now first determine which supplies the claimant made within its single business.

According to the decision, mere participation in races does not constitute an economic activity. An input VAT deduction is therefore generally precluded in this respect. However, the claimant may have fulfilled its obligations under the sponsorship agreements by displaying sponsors’ logos on racing cars and racing apparel and participating in the X-Cup.

The Finanzgericht must therefore also determine whether participation in the racing events was attributable to the claimant at all. According to the auditors’ findings, the clinic is said to have owned the racing team. Insofar as participation in the races can be attributed to the claimant, it may have formed part of its business activity.

In that event, motor-racing-related input transactions could, in principle, fall within § 15(1), sentence 1, no. 1 UStG. However, the deduction could be excluded under § 15(1a) UStG in conjunction with § 4(5), sentence 1, no. 4 and sentence 2 EStG. If, for example, the input VAT deduction for the supply of a racing car is denied on this basis, its subsequent supply would be exempt from VAT under § 4 no. 28 UStG.

The claimant’s duty to cooperate

In the further proceedings, the claimant must specify the individual input transactions for which it seeks an input VAT deduction. It must also explain why each transaction was obtained for its business and used for taxed output transactions.

The Finanzgericht is not required to search through more than 1,500 pages of exhibits to identify the documents that might support an asserted input VAT deduction. The claimant must submit the documents in an organised manner and prepare their content so that the requirements under § 15 UStG can be examined. The court may then, where appropriate, limit its review to samples.

Where a direct connection is established between individual, properly invoiced input transactions and the taxable economic activity, the input VAT amounts already recognised must also be taken into account. An additional deduction is possible only insofar as the input VAT amounts established in the proceedings exceed the amounts already recognised.

Significance of the decision for input VAT deduction

The judgment clearly distinguishes the recognition of business expenses for income tax purposes from the VAT requirements governing input VAT deductions. Even if expenses are estimated for the profit calculation and recognised as business expenses, this does not give rise to a corresponding right to deduct input VAT. Specific input transactions, their receipt for the business, their use for taxed transactions and proper invoices remain necessary.

The final VAT assessment of the dispute remains outstanding. The Hessisches Finanzgericht must make the missing findings and reassess both the claimed input transactions and the overall circumstances of the short-term vehicle transaction. The decision on costs was also delegated to the Finanzgericht.

For questions concerning the VAT treatment of business expenses, input VAT deduction or the tax classification of business vehicle transactions, MTR Legal advises companies, investors and private individuals as part of its tax law advisory services.

Sources

More articles

BFH zur gewinnneutralen Berichtigung der Eröffnungsbilanz – Foto: Usman Malik auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH on Tax-Neutral Correction of Opening Balance Sheets

November 20, 2026

StaRUG erfasst Bürgschaften von Geschäftsführern nicht – Foto: Matheus Lara / Pexels

Insolvency Law

StaRUG Does Not Cover Guarantees by Managing Directors

November 20, 2026

BFH begrenzt Versagung des Vorsteuerabzugs – Foto: Zlaťáky.cz auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH Limits Denial of Input VAT Deduction

November 20, 2026

Book a callback

Available now17:17

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220