By order dated 24 September 2026 (Az. [case no.] IX ZB 5/26), the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice) issued an important decision on the eligibility of natural persons for restructuring under the Unternehmensstabilisierungs- und -restrukturierungsgesetz (StaRUG, German Act on the Stabilisation and Restructuring Framework for Businesses).
The central issue in the decision was whether a limited partner in a GmbH & Co. KG who is also a managing director and shareholder of its general partner GmbH can use a restructuring plan under StaRUG to modify their personal liabilities arising from guarantees they have provided.
The BGH answered this question in the negative. A mere interest in a company and activity as a managing director do not, in themselves, constitute business activity within the meaning of § 30 Abs. 1 Satz 2 StaRUG (section 30(1), second sentence, of the German Act on the Stabilisation and Restructuring Framework for Businesses). Accordingly, liabilities arising from corresponding shareholder guarantees generally cannot be included in a restructuring plan.
Guarantee obligations amounting to millions
The order was based on the following facts: The debtor was a limited partner in a GmbH & Co. KG. Its sole general partner was a management GmbH. The debtor held a 50% interest in this general partner GmbH. At the same time, he served as its managing director.
In addition, he held a 25% interest in another GmbH. According to his own statements, he also operated an independent consultancy business under his own business name.
The debtor had provided directly enforceable guarantees to several banks for liabilities of the GmbH & Co. KG. As a result, he faced a substantial personal liability risk.
On 1 September 2025, insolvency proceedings were opened over the assets of the GmbH & Co. KG. After insolvency proceedings had been opened over the assets of the KG, the debtor pursued his own restructuring project under StaRUG.
Proposed restructuring plan
The debtor intended to reorganise his personal liabilities by means of a restructuring plan.
For this purpose, the proposed restructuring plan provided for three groups of creditors:
-
First group of creditors: Banks asserting claims against the debtor under his directly enforceable guarantees for liabilities of the GmbH & Co. KG.
-
Second group of creditors: Small creditors.
-
Third group of creditors: Other ordinary restructuring creditors with an interest in preserving the business.
The claims arising from the guarantees provided formed the principal subject matter of the restructuring project.
The debtor’s position
The debtor took the view that he should be regarded as a natural person engaged in business activity.
He based this position in particular on his work as managing director and his status as a shareholder or partner in the GmbH & Co. KG and the general partner GmbH. He also referred to the consultancy business he operated independently.
In his view, the liabilities arising from the guarantees were therefore also eligible for restructuring under StaRUG.
He further argued that enforcement of the guarantees would jeopardise the continuation of his consultancy business and might result in its break-up.
Decisions of the lower courts
By order dated 9 November 2025 – 603 RES 1/25, the Amtsgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Local Court), acting as the restructuring court, terminated the restructuring matter on the grounds that it had no prospect of success.
The immediate appeal lodged against that decision was unsuccessful before the Landgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Regional Court).
The debtor then continued to pursue his application before the Bundesgerichtshof by way of the admitted appeal on points of law.
Decision of the Bundesgerichtshof
The Bundesgerichtshof dismissed the debtor’s appeal on points of law.
It thereby upheld the decisions of the lower courts and clarified that personal liabilities arising from the shareholder guarantees provided cannot be modified by means of a restructuring plan under StaRUG.
The decisive factor was that the guarantee liabilities at issue did not result from the debtor’s own business activity.
Mere shareholder status does not constitute business activity
According to the BGH, neither an interest in a limited partnership nor an interest in a corporation generally constitutes independent economic or business activity within the meaning of StaRUG.
Nor does acting as managing director of a GmbH engaged in business activity automatically mean that the managing director is personally engaged in business activity.
Acting as a corporate officer on behalf of a company must be distinguished from the natural person’s own business activity.
Guarantee liabilities not eligible for restructuring
The BGH also clarified that liabilities arising from a directly enforceable guarantee are not to be classified as business liabilities solely because the guarantee was provided to secure company liabilities.
The fact that the debtor was also a shareholder and managing director of the company did not alter this conclusion.
Rather, the guarantee establishes personal liability to the respective creditor. It does not, however, make the guarantor a person engaged in business activity within the meaning of StaRUG.
The personal guarantee liabilities were therefore not capable of being modified by a restructuring plan.
Reasoning of the Bundesgerichtshof
The BGH’s reasoning is particularly significant with regard to the interpretation of the concept of business activity under § 30 Abs. 1 Satz 2 StaRUG.
Autonomous interpretation of the concept of an entrepreneur under StaRUG
The BGH first considered when a natural person is to be regarded as engaged in business activity within the meaning of StaRUG.
The decisive factor is not merely whether the person concerned is connected to a business in some way or pursues an economic interest in a company.
Rather, the relevant question is whether the natural person personally carries on a business activity.
The business activity must therefore be attributable to the natural person themselves.
Mere shareholder status is generally insufficient for this purpose. This applies both to an interest in a GmbH and to the status of a limited partner in a GmbH & Co. KG.
Distinction from the case law on consumer insolvency law
The BGH’s analysis of its previous case law on consumer insolvency law is particularly noteworthy.
According to earlier decisions of the BGH, a sole or majority shareholder who is also the managing director of a GmbH may carry on an independent economic activity within the meaning of § 304 InsO (section 304 of the Insolvenzordnung, German Insolvency Code).
The BGH had reasoned that, from an economic perspective, such a shareholder-managing director occupies an entrepreneurial position and may typically also face liabilities characteristic of self-employed entrepreneurs.
However, the BGH did not apply this case law to StaRUG.
The different assessment is explained by the different regulatory purposes of the legislation:
-
Consumer insolvency law serves in particular to allocate natural persons to the different types of insolvency proceedings.
-
StaRUG, by contrast, aims to stabilise and restructure businesses within a preventive restructuring framework.
The requirements for business activity must therefore be determined independently in light of the respective regulatory purpose.
A natural person may consequently be regarded as carrying on an independent economic activity under consumer insolvency law without also carrying on business activity within the meaning of StaRUG.
A guarantee does not constitute the guarantor’s own business activity
Another key aspect of the decision concerns the legal classification of the guarantees provided.
The BGH held that providing a guarantee for company liabilities does not constitute an independent business activity on the part of the guarantor.
The guarantee serves to secure the creditor’s claims. The guarantor thereby assumes the personal liability risk in the event that the principal debtor fails to perform its obligations.
However, this fact alone does not make the guarantor an entrepreneur.
This also applies where the guarantor is both a shareholder and managing director of the company whose liabilities were secured.
The decisive point remains that personal liability under a guarantee cannot be equated with the guarantor’s own business activity.
No extension of the scope of application to personal debt relief
In its decision, the BGH also made clear that StaRUG is not intended to relieve natural persons of personal liabilities that arose merely in connection with a company’s business activity.
Under German law, personal debt relief for natural persons is generally obtained through insolvency proceedings.
Restructuring proceedings, by contrast, are intended to facilitate the restructuring of a business.
Extending StaRUG to personal guarantee liabilities would go beyond this statutory objective.
The personal liability of a shareholder or managing director for company liabilities is therefore insufficient to provide access to restructuring proceedings.
Legal significance and practical implications of the decision
The BGH’s order is of considerable practical significance for shareholder-managing directors who have provided personal guarantees for their company’s liabilities.
In particular, the decision makes clear that a company’s business activity cannot automatically be attributed to its shareholders or managing directors.
For StaRUG to apply, the business activity of the respective natural person must instead be assessed independently.
In practice, the decision has the following consequences in particular:
-
A mere interest in a GmbH or GmbH & Co. KG generally does not constitute business activity within the meaning of StaRUG.
-
Nor is acting as managing director of a GmbH engaged in business activity automatically sufficient for this purpose.
-
Personal guarantee liabilities for company debts are not eligible for restructuring solely because of their business context.
-
StaRUG cannot be used to relieve natural persons of personal liability obligations arising from shareholder guarantees.
Of particular importance in this regard is the distinction between a company’s business activity and the own business activity of its shareholder or managing director.
A natural person may certainly carry on an independent business activity. However, it does not automatically follow that all personal liabilities assumed in connection with that person’s equity interest in a company can be included in a restructuring plan.
Conclusion
By order dated 24 September 2026 (Az. IX ZB 5/26), the BGH clarified the limits on the eligibility of natural persons for restructuring under StaRUG.
Mere shareholder status or activity as a managing director is insufficient to establish business activity within the meaning of § 30 Abs. 1 Satz 2 StaRUG. In particular, personal liabilities arising from shareholder guarantees cannot be included in a restructuring plan solely because they serve to finance or secure a company engaged in business activity.
The decision thus highlights the clear distinction between restructuring a business and providing personal debt relief to its shareholders and managing directors.
MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte advises companies, shareholders and managing directors on assessing and addressing such matters. Its advisory services include, among other areas, legal advice on insolvency law.