Menu

BFH Limits Denial of Input VAT Deduction

Published on November 20, 2026

The Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) has clarified the requirements for denying input VAT deduction in transactions tainted by tax evasion (BFH, judgment of 16 July 2026 – V R 31/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.160726.VR31.25.0). Accordingly, it is not sufficient for a supplier or upstream supplier to have improperly claimed input VAT based on sham invoices independently of the specific supply chain. Rather, the tax evasion must concern an upstream or downstream transaction specifically within the supply chain from which the recipient claims the input VAT deduction.

Dispute over input VAT deduction from supplies of precious metals

Supply relationships between the companies involved

The proceedings concerned the deduction of input VAT from supplies of precious metals by A-GmbH to B-GmbH in 2012. In accordance with the agreement between the companies, self-billing invoices were issued for the supplies.

A-GmbH’s accounting records indicated that it had previously purchased the precious metals resold to B-GmbH from X-GmbH and Y-GmbH. Neither company had submitted preliminary VAT returns or an annual VAT return for the year in dispute.

In its preliminary returns for August to December 2012, A-GmbH treated the VAT invoiced by these two companies as deductible input VAT. In the same preliminary return periods, it declared the supplies to B-GmbH. B-GmbH, in turn, deducted as input VAT the VAT shown in the self-billing invoices for the supplies made by A-GmbH.

Conviction of the supplier’s managing director

The managing director of A-GmbH was sentenced to a term of imprisonment for tax evasion. The conviction was based on his submission of incorrect preliminary VAT returns for August to December 2012. By deducting input VAT from sham invoices issued by X-GmbH and Y-GmbH, A-GmbH’s tax liability had been reduced even though the managing director knew that these companies had not supplied any precious metals to A-GmbH.

Following criminal investigations, the Finanzamt (tax office) assumed that B-GmbH had participated in a deliberately established supply chain intended to facilitate VAT fraud. It therefore denied the input VAT deduction from the supplies made by A-GmbH and increased the VAT assessment for 2012 accordingly.

Insolvency proceedings and procedural history

Resumption of the suspended objection proceedings

During the objection proceedings, insolvency proceedings were opened over the assets of B-GmbH. The insolvency administrator initially appointed contested the claims filed by the Finanzamt and resumed the objection proceedings that had been suspended by the opening of the insolvency proceedings.

In its decision on the objection, the Finanzamt treated the proceedings as declaratory proceedings. It considered the objection to the tax claim filed in the insolvency schedule to be unfounded and, relying on § 251 Abs. 3 AO (German Fiscal Code), determined, among other matters, the VAT for 2012. The input VAT amounts from the supplies made by A-GmbH remained excluded.

Action dismissed twice by the Finanzgericht

The Finanzgericht Münster (Münster Fiscal Court) dismissed the action in the first round of proceedings. After the action had been brought, the claimant was appointed as the new insolvency administrator over the assets of B-GmbH. By order of 13 July 2021 – XI B 30/20, the BFH set aside the Fiscal Court’s first decision and remitted the dispute.

The action was also unsuccessful in the second round of proceedings. The Finanzgericht did not regard the determination of the filed tax claims as a separate declaratory administrative act under § 251 Abs. 3 AO, but as a non-independent part of the decision on the objection.

Furthermore, the Finanzgericht considered the denial of input VAT deduction to be lawful. Although the supplies invoiced to B-GmbH had actually been made, the court held that B-GmbH should at least have recognised that its purchases were connected with VAT evasion committed at an upstream transaction stage. In this respect, the Finanzgericht found gross negligence.

Principle of transaction-specific assessment

Under § 15 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 1 Satz 1 UStG (German Value Added Tax Act), a taxable person may deduct as input VAT the tax legally due on supplies made to their business by another taxable person. Under EU law, this provision is based on Art. 168 Buchst. a of the VAT Directive.

For VAT purposes, each transaction must generally be assessed independently. Events at upstream or downstream stages do not alter the nature of a specific transaction within a supply chain. Likewise, the right of deduction does not depend on whether the VAT due on earlier or subsequent sales was actually paid to the tax authorities.

According to the case law of the Gerichtshof der Europäischen Union (Court of Justice of the European Union), an exception applies where objective circumstances establish that the taxable person knew or should have known that their purchase was connected with tax evasion. The evasion must have been committed by the supplier, the service provider or another economic operator at an upstream or downstream stage of the specific supply chain.

No general exclusion based on breaches of duty by the supplier

According to the BFH, a taxable person claiming an input VAT deduction cannot generally be required to investigate all of the invoice issuer’s tax affairs. This applies in particular to the questions of whether the invoice issuer:

  • is a taxable person,
  • had the goods concerned at its disposal and was able to supply them, or
  • complied with its VAT filing obligations.

There is even less justification for imposing a comprehensive duty, detached from the specific transaction, to monitor the supplier’s compliance with its tax obligations.

In the case of a supply of goods, the objective requirements for fraud-related denial of input VAT deduction are met only if either the specific upstream or downstream supply was not declared as a transaction despite being taxable and subject to VAT, or input VAT was improperly claimed for an upstream or downstream supply of the same goods.

Sham invoices outside the supply chain are insufficient

X-GmbH and Y-GmbH were not part of the actual supply chain

The BFH objected to the fact that the Finanzgericht had relied solely on A-GmbH having improperly deducted input VAT from the sham invoices issued by X-GmbH and Y-GmbH. This circumstance did not justify denying B-GmbH the input VAT deduction.

According to the findings of the Finanzgericht, X-GmbH and Y-GmbH had not supplied any precious metals to A-GmbH. They therefore did not form part of the actual supply chain through which the precious metals reached B-GmbH. They were merely identified as the issuers of the invoices that A-GmbH had used to claim its improper input VAT deduction.

The tax evasion benefiting A-GmbH thus did not concern any upstream supply of the precious metals subsequently sold to B-GmbH. There was no actual supply chain running from X-GmbH or Y-GmbH through A-GmbH to B-GmbH.

Accounting allocation does not create an objective connection

The precious metals traded were fungible goods defined only by their class. The connection between the sham invoices and the supplies to B-GmbH arose solely from the fact that A-GmbH had incorrectly recorded a purchase from X-GmbH and Y-GmbH in its accounts.

According to the BFH, an accounting connection created solely by the supplier is insufficient. An objectively existing link to tax evasion at an upstream or downstream stage of the actual supply chain is required. A-GmbH had not claimed the improper input VAT deduction for an upstream supply of the same precious metals, but merely in connection with their onward supply.

This distinction is consistent with the parallel decision of the BFH issued on the same day, 16 July 2026 – V R 28/24. In that decision too, the BFH clarified that tax evasion committed through sham invoices outside the specific supply chain does not automatically preclude the recipient’s input VAT deduction.

Remittal to the Finanzgericht Münster

Further findings concerning unknown suppliers required

The BFH set aside the decision of the Finanzgericht Münster. However, it was unable to issue a final decision on the input VAT deduction because the necessary findings of fact were lacking.

According to the BFH, tax evasion could not be established in relation to A-GmbH’s supplies to B-GmbH themselves. A-GmbH had declared these output transactions in its preliminary VAT returns for the year in dispute, and this was not disputed by the parties.

It remained unclear, however, from which actual suppliers A-GmbH had obtained the precious metals and whether tax evasion had been committed at that upstream transaction stage. In this regard, the Finanzgericht had merely reproduced a statement by A-GmbH’s managing director according to which he had received the goods from persons who had not been fully identified in a commercial area, “from one car boot to another”.

In the further proceedings, the Finanzgericht must therefore determine in particular:

  • whether the actual supplies to A-GmbH were connected with tax evasion at an upstream transaction stage, and
  • whether the persons acting on behalf of B-GmbH should have known about this.

The proceedings have therefore not yet been concluded. The Finanzgericht Münster must rehear and decide the issue of the claimed input VAT deduction.

Determination of the insolvency claim remains possible

At the same time, the BFH confirmed the Finanzgericht’s assessment of the procedural position under insolvency law. If a contested tax assessment already existed when the insolvency proceedings were opened and the insolvency administrator disputes the filed claim, the suspended legal remedy proceedings must be resumed. The required declaratory ruling may be included in the decision on the objection.

The BFH additionally noted that, according to the case law of the EuGH (Court of Justice of the European Union), liability provisions such as § 25d UStG in the version applicable to the year in dispute do not preclude denial of input VAT deduction on another legal basis. In light of the proceedings as they then stood, it was not necessary to decide which basis under national law applies to the EU-law principles for tax periods prior to the entry into force of § 25f UStG.

Significance for VAT supply chains

The decision distinguishes between tax evasion within the specific supply chain and a merely accompanying, independent VAT offence. Accordingly, even a supplier’s improper input VAT deduction based on sham invoices does not, by itself, result in the recipient losing the right of deduction. The decisive issue remains whether the evasion specifically concerns an upstream or downstream transaction stage involving the relevant goods or services and whether the recipient knew or should have known about it.

The actual allocation of transactions and the findings concerning the individual stages of a supply chain may therefore be decisive for VAT purposes. For questions concerning the implications of the BFH decision and the treatment of input VAT deduction, MTR Legal offers legal advice on tax law.

Sources

More articles

BFH zur gewinnneutralen Berichtigung der Eröffnungsbilanz – Foto: Usman Malik auf Unsplash

Tax Law

BFH on Tax-Neutral Correction of Opening Balance Sheets

November 20, 2026

StaRUG erfasst Bürgschaften von Geschäftsführern nicht – Foto: Matheus Lara / Pexels

Insolvency Law

StaRUG Does Not Cover Guarantees by Managing Directors

November 20, 2026

Urheberrecht: LG Köln stärkt Schutz vor Video-Uploads – Foto: Mizuno K / Pexels

Copyright Law

Copyright: LG Köln strengthens protection against video uploads

November 20, 2026

Book a callback

Available now16:17

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220