The Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court) has upheld the rejection of special abuse proceedings against a grid operator (OLG Düsseldorf, order dated 4 November 2026 – VI-5 Kart 4/26 [V] (case no.)). According to the decision of the 5th Cartel Division, the Bundesnetzagentur (Federal Network Agency) was entitled to refrain from initiating such proceedings in response to the change in the allocation of grid connection capacity from the first-come, first-served principle to a pro rata allocation procedure.
Changed allocation of scarce grid connection capacity
Original allocation in chronological order
The grid operator concerned initially allocated available grid connection capacity on a “first come, first served” basis. Accordingly, the chronological order in which applications were submitted was generally decisive.
Since 2022, the appellant, a company active in real estate development, had applied several times for grid connection capacity to operate a data centre. In doing so, it repeatedly expanded the scope of its request. The most recent application, submitted in December 2023, concerned a volume equivalent to approximately ten per cent of the annual peak load of a city such as Berlin.
In June 2024, the grid operator confirmed that the documents submitted were complete. By that time, demand for grid connections had increased considerably and, in total, significantly exceeded the capacity available in the distribution and transmission grids.
Retroactive introduction of the pro rata allocation procedure
The grid operator amended its grid connection terms in July 2024 with effect from 1 January 2024. The newly introduced pro rata allocation procedure covers all applications that had not yet been submitted in full by this cut-off date.
Under the amended terms, the available connection capacity is allocated equally once a year, on a specified cut-off date, among eligible applicants for grid connections. Requests for capacity exceeding 3.5 MVA are included.
Bundesnetzagentur rejected abuse proceedings
The appellant considered the change in procedure to be abusive. It applied to the Bundesnetzagentur for the initiation of special abuse proceedings against the grid operator. Its objective was to ensure that its connection application continued to be processed on a first-come, first-served basis.
The Bundesnetzagentur rejected the application by order dated 26 May 2025. It based its decision on the lawfulness of the grid operator’s approach. The appeal lodged against that decision was unsuccessful before the Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf.
Pro rata allocation lawful in the court’s view
Requirements of § 17 Abs. 1 EnWG met
In view of the limited grid connection capacity, the 5th Cartel Division considered the switch to the pro rata allocation procedure lawful. In the court’s view, this form of allocation does not, in particular, infringe § 17 Abs. 1 EnWG (German Energy Industry Act).
The procedure ensures non-discriminatory allocation where capacity is scarce. It is also transparent and appropriate. The existing capacity shortage, which is expected to become even more acute in the future, made it imperative to change the previous allocation model.
Risks of the first-come, first-served principle
The Oberlandesgericht considered the first-come, first-served principle no longer appropriate under the changed circumstances. Had it been retained, the following risks would have arisen in particular:
-
Companies could have secured connection capacity through strategic applications at very early stages of their projects.
-
Applied-for capacity could have been tied up for an extended period without actually being used.
-
Particularly large projects could have claimed all available capacity, thereby excluding other grid connection applicants in the long term.
In the Division’s assessment, the chosen pro rata allocation procedure appropriately addresses these risks. At the same time, despite the particularly substantial capacity requested, the appellant is not excluded from an allocation from the outset.
Retroactive application reasonable in the absence of an established legal entitlement
The Oberlandesgericht also raised no objection to the retroactive application of the amended terms. The decisive factor was that, when the pro rata allocation procedure was introduced, the appellant did not yet have an established legal entitlement to the grid connection capacity requested.
Under these circumstances, the court considered it reasonable for its application to be included in the new allocation procedure. The fact that its application had been submitted earlier therefore did not mean that the first-come, first-served principle had to continue to apply to its connection request.
Order not yet final
The decision is not yet final. The Division granted leave to appeal on points of law to the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH, Federal Court of Justice), meaning that the appellant may pursue this legal remedy.
MTR Legal advises companies, investors and high-net-worth private individuals as part of its competition law advisory services..