Menu

GDPR Fines for Access Requests and Email Accounts

Italian data protection authority imposes fines totalling €25,500

Published on November 18, 2026

Italian data protection authority imposes fines totalling €25,500

On 20 October 2026, the Italian data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, imposed two fines totalling €25,500 on Techpartner S.r.l. According to the Garante, the Modena-based company supplies equipment to the food industry.

The decision concerned the handling of a former employee’s access request and the company’s internal policies governing personal corporate email accounts. The authority found infringements of Art. 5(1)(a), (c) and (e), Art. 12(3) and Art. 15 GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation).

Complaint by a former employee

The proceedings arose from a complaint lodged by a former employee. He alleged that the company had failed to respond appropriately to his request for access to the personal data processed during his employment.

Response provided only after the investigation began

According to the Garante’s findings, Techpartner did not respond to the request until approximately nine months after receiving it and only after the authority had initiated its investigation. Art. 12(3) GDPR generally requires information on action taken in response to a request under Arts. 15 to 22 GDPR to be provided without undue delay and, in any event, within one month of receipt of the request.

The company argued that it had not recognised the request as a request under the GDPR. It also claimed that a corporate merger had caused difficulties. The Garante rejected these arguments. The request had expressly referred to data protection law. Furthermore, the company could have made use of the available option to extend the deadline.

At the same time, the authority clarified that the obligation to process the request within the applicable time limit also applies where a data subject access request forms part of a more extensive letter concerning employment law matters. It imposed a fine of €9,500 for the delayed response.

Data protection shortcomings relating to corporate email accounts

In addition to the access request, the Garante examined the company’s internal policies governing the use of personal corporate email accounts. The review focused in particular on how accounts were handled after the termination of employment.

Accounts kept active after employees had left

The internal policies allowed the email accounts of former employees to remain active for a further three to six months after they had left the company. During this period, incoming messages could be read.

In the Garante’s view, this practice was incompatible with several principles under Art. 5 GDPR. The authority found infringements of the following requirements:

  • The processing did not comply with the principle of lawfulness under Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR.
  • The arrangements did not satisfy the principle of data minimisation under Art. 5(1)(c) GDPR.
  • The retention period was incompatible with the storage limitation principle under Art. 5(1)(e) GDPR.

The authority imposed a further fine of €16,000 for the unlawful processing associated with the corporate email accounts.

Requirements for the accounts of former employees

The Garante reiterated that personal corporate email accounts must be deactivated and deleted once the employment relationship has ended. Senders of incoming messages should be informed automatically that the account has been deactivated and directed to alternative contact details.

According to the authority’s assessment, technical measures must also ensure that the employer is unable to read messages sent to the deactivated account. These requirements protect both the personal data of the former employee and the data of the respective senders.

No infringements found in relation to further allegations

The investigation also covered allegations concerning video surveillance and the handling of occupational health information. The Garante found no infringements in this regard. This applied in particular to the disclosure to third parties of information concerning an invitation to undergo an occupational health fitness assessment.

The allegations under Art. 88 GDPR and Art. 114 of the Italian Data Protection Code were also dismissed. The authority’s findings were therefore limited to the delayed handling of the access request and the processing of personal data in connection with the corporate email accounts.

Company ordered to amend its internal IT policies

In addition to the two fines, the Garante ordered Techpartner to bring its internal IT usage policies into compliance with data protection requirements within 60 days of notification of the decision. The order concerns the relevant policies applicable both during and after employment.

The decision highlights the importance of clear internal procedures for handling data subject requests and managing personal corporate email accounts. Companies and affected individuals may contact MTR Legal with questions regarding the resulting requirements and obtain tailored legal advice on data protection law.

Sources

More articles

BFH: Volle Erbfallkostenpauschale für Vermächtnisnehmer – Foto: RDNE Stock project / Pexels

Tax Law

BFH: Full Inheritance Cost Allowance for Legatees

November 18, 2026

OLG Frankfurt: Sondervotum rechtfertigt keine Aufhebung – Bild: Free-Photos / Pixabay

Litigation

Frankfurt Higher Regional Court: Dissent No Ground for Setting Aside

November 18, 2026

BGH zu Schwarzlohnzahlungen und Steuerhinterziehung – Foto: Davide Locatelli / Pexels

White-Collar Criminal Law

BGH on Undeclared Wage Payments and Tax Evasion

November 18, 2026

Book a callback

Available now15:40

We will call you back at your preferred time. Confirmed immediately. Choose your appointment on our contact page.

Choose appointment

Prefer to talk directly? +49 221 9999220