The Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main (Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main) has ruled that the publication of a dissenting opinion by an arbitrator does not, in itself, constitute grounds for setting aside a domestic arbitral award (OLG Frankfurt am Main, order dated 6 November 2026 – 32 Sch 3/26). The 32nd Senate, which has jurisdiction over arbitration proceedings, dismissed the application to set aside the award. The decision is subject to appeal.
Dispute over the termination of a distribution agreement
Arbitration proceedings following termination of the agreement
In 2009, the parties entered into a distribution agreement concerning dialysis equipment. In 2018, the party that subsequently became the respondent terminated the agreement. The parties then initiated arbitration proceedings in which they disputed the validity of the termination as well as potential claims for damages and performance.
In its arbitral award of October 2019, the arbitral tribunal dismissed the claim. On the counterclaim, it ordered the claimant to pay damages of approximately EUR 1.25 million.
Dissenting view of an arbitrator
The arbitral tribunal consisted of three arbitrators. One of them issued a dissenting opinion on the arbitral award, setting out a view that differed from the majority decision on individual issues addressed in the proceedings. Both the arbitral award and the dissenting opinion were transmitted to the parties.
The claimant subsequently applied to have the arbitral award set aside. It argued that, by publishing the dissenting opinion, the arbitral tribunal had breached the confidentiality of deliberations.
No violation of procedural public policy
Requirements for setting aside an arbitral award
The 32nd Senate of the Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main found that there were no grounds for setting aside the award. In its assessment, neither the issuance of a dissenting opinion as such nor an alleged resulting violation of public policy warrants setting aside the arbitral award.
A domestic arbitral award violates procedural public policy if the arbitral tribunal has disregarded a party’s fundamental procedural right and the arbitral award is based on that violation. In the Senate’s view, these requirements were not met.
Confidentiality of deliberations also applies to arbitrators
German arbitration law does not expressly regulate whether an arbitrator may publish a dissenting opinion. According to the Senate, the confidentiality of deliberations enshrined in the Deutsches Richtergesetz (German Judiciary Act) also applies to arbitrators.
In the Court’s view, a dissenting opinion issued after the conclusion of the proceedings does not, in any event, breach the confidentiality of deliberations to such an extent that its disclosure following deliberation and decision-making would be manifestly incompatible with fundamental principles of German law.
Considerations concerning the permissibility of a dissenting opinion
Dissenting opinions are not alien to German law
The Senate took into account that dissenting opinions are also provided for under German law. A member of the Bundesverfassungsgericht (Federal Constitutional Court) may set out in a dissenting opinion the view expressed during deliberations that differs from the decision or its reasoning.
The Court cited several considerations supporting the conclusion that such an opinion may be permissible in arbitration proceedings:
- At the time the dissenting opinion was disclosed, the other arbitrators were no longer in need of protection with regard to the majority decision.
- If the mere transmission of a dissenting opinion were sufficient to have the arbitral award set aside, the dissenting arbitrator would be given considerable leverage.
- The draft legislation to modernise arbitration law expressly provides that a dissenting opinion on an arbitral award may be recorded separately.
According to the Senate, the explanatory memorandum to this draft legislation shows that the legislature considers dissenting opinions permissible even under the law currently in force. The proposed statutory provision is intended merely to clarify the legal position in this respect.
Significance of the confidentiality of deliberations
Judges are generally required to maintain confidentiality regarding the course of deliberations and voting. The confidentiality of deliberations safeguards judicial independence and generally precludes the public presentation of dissenting views in a separate statement.
A special rule applies to the Bundesverfassungsgericht, under which the publication of a dissenting opinion is permissible. The order of the Oberlandesgericht does not extend this exception generally to arbitration proceedings. Rather, it is based on the finding that, in the case decided, the dissenting opinion published after the conclusion of the proceedings did not constitute a violation that justified setting aside the arbitral award on the grounds of incompatibility with public policy.
Advice on disputes before state courts and arbitral tribunals
The decision makes clear that not every potential breach of the confidentiality of deliberations provides sufficient grounds for setting aside an arbitral award. The decisive factors remain the requirements of procedural public policy and whether the arbitral award is based on a failure to respect fundamental procedural rights. MTR Legal assists companies, investors and private individuals with the judicial enforcement of and defence against claims as well as disputes arising under arbitration law as part of its legal advice on litigation.