The Bundesfinanzhof (BFH, Federal Fiscal Court) has clarified the liability of a former GmbH managing director in connection with a practice known as corporate burial (BFH, judgment of 8 September 2026 – VII R 14/25 (case no.), ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.080926.VIIR14.25.0BFH). According to the ruling, a shareholders’ resolution concerning a change of managing director is not void in this context, but merely voidable. Nevertheless, the former managing director may still be held liable if, prior to leaving office, they breached their duty to safeguard funds.
Change of management and subsequent deletion from the register
Since 2013, the claimant and respondent in the appeal proceedings had been the sole shareholder and managing director of a GmbH. The company filed tax returns up to and including 2017 and was assessed accordingly. Its balance sheet as at 31 December 2017 reported a net profit for the financial year. Work in progress and advance payments received on orders were also recognised in the balance sheet.
Removal of the previous managing director
In May 2018, the claimant removed himself as managing director with immediate effect by means of a written shareholders’ resolution and appointed a new managing director residing in Bulgaria. The change was entered in the Handelsregister (German Commercial Register) in June 2018. The existing business address initially remained unchanged.
In January 2019, the claimant removed this managing director and appointed another managing director. On the same day, he transferred his shares to that person. The purchase price and payment terms were to be set out in a separate instrument that was not included in the case file.
In May 2019, another change of management was resolved. New business addresses were subsequently registered in succession.
Tax assessments based on estimates
The GmbH did not file any tax returns for the 2018 and 2019 assessment periods. The Finanzamt (German tax office) therefore assessed corporation tax and VAT on an estimated basis. The assessment notices had to be served by public notice.
In October 2021, the GmbH was deleted ex officio from the Handelsregister due to a lack of assets. Financial statements for 2018 and 2019 also remained outstanding.
By a liability notice dated 31 July 2023, the Finanzamt held the former managing director liable for outstanding corporation tax and VAT, ancillary tax charges and enforcement costs. It took the view that the claimant’s removal and the subsequent transfer of the shares formed part of a corporate burial and were invalid because they prejudiced creditors. It also maintained that the claimant had breached his duty to retain funds for the taxes that would subsequently arise.
Finanzgericht rejected liability
The Schleswig-Holsteinisches Finanzgericht (Schleswig-Holstein Fiscal Court) upheld the action against the liability notice. In its view, the claimant could not be held liable as managing director under § 69 Satz 1 in conjunction with § 34 Abs. 1 Satz 1 AO (German Fiscal Code).
End of status as legal representative
The Finanzgericht held that the claimant’s status as a corporate officer had ended upon his removal in May 2018. The shareholders’ resolution was not contrary to public policy and was therefore not void. For the subsequent period, the claimant was no longer required to fulfil the GmbH’s tax obligations as its managing director.
According to the Finanzgericht’s assessment, the requirements for a corporate burial were not met. In particular, it referred to the following considerations:
- It had not been established that the GmbH was in financial distress at the time of the removal.
- The balance sheet as at 31 December 2017 reported a net profit for the financial year.
- Neither the company name nor the business address or registered office under the articles of association was changed in the immediate temporal context of the removal.
- No sufficient indications of a transfer of assets had been established.
- It had not been established that the newly appointed managing director was unable or unwilling to manage the company’s affairs.
- The claimant’s removal and the transfer of his shares did not occur in an immediate temporal context.
The Finanzgericht also found neither a breach of the duty to safeguard funds prior to the removal nor that the claimant had acted as a de facto managing director after leaving office.
BFH confirms validity of removal
The BFH set aside the Finanzgericht’s decision and remitted the case for a new hearing and decision. The findings of fact made to date were insufficient for a final decision on liability.
Change of managing director is not automatically void
The BFH first confirmed that the claimant had lost his status as the GmbH’s legal representative upon his removal. Under § 34 Abs. 1 Satz 1 AO, the legal representatives of a corporation are required to fulfil its tax obligations. Under § 35 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GmbHG (German Limited Liability Companies Act), a GmbH is legally represented by its managing director.
Status as managing director requires a valid and continuing appointment. In the event of revocation, it generally ends when the revocation is received, rather than only when the termination of the appointment is entered in the Handelsregister.
In the BFH’s view, the resolution removing the claimant was not invalid under civil law. Resolutions adopted by the shareholders’ meeting of a GmbH in connection with a corporate burial are not automatically void.
Meaning of corporate burial
Corporate burial refers to a course of conduct in which those responsible covertly liquidate a company in order to avoid insolvency proceedings or delay them for as long as possible. As part of this process, assets are typically transferred systematically to related parties, successor companies or affiliated third parties, while creditors’ claims are no longer satisfied.
External indications may include, in particular, the replacement of management, the sale of all shares in the company, the loss of business records and a subsequent insolvency application where there are no realisable assets. Whether such systematic conduct exists must be assessed in light of the actual circumstances of the individual case.
Only the content of the resolution is relevant to whether it is void
Under the principles applied by the BFH, whether a shareholders’ resolution is contrary to public policy is not assessed directly under § 138 BGB (German Civil Code), but by analogous application of § 241 Nr. 4 AktG (German Stock Corporation Act). Accordingly, a resolution is void only if its content, taken by itself, is contrary to public policy.
If only the motive, purpose or manner in which the resolution was adopted is contrary to public policy, this generally makes the resolution merely voidable. An exception may apply if a resolution interferes with inalienable shareholder rights or directly harms creditors who have no right of challenge of their own.
According to the binding findings of the Finanzgericht, the resolution of May 2018 dealt exclusively with the claimant’s removal and the appointment of a new managing director. No further resolutions interfering with the company’s structure or directly harming creditors had been established. The change of managing director was therefore valid.
Liability possible despite valid departure from office
According to the judgment, the valid removal does not mean that liability for prior conduct is excluded. A former managing director may be held liable under § 69 Satz 1 AO if, during their term of office, they intentionally or with gross negligence breached tax obligations and thereby caused a loss giving rise to liability.
Duty to safeguard funds applies before the due date
A managing director must not wait until a tax becomes due before ensuring that sufficient funds are available. The duty to safeguard funds requires forward-looking planning. Particularly in times of crisis, financial resources must be retained to settle foreseeable tax liabilities.
The specific scope of this duty depends on the circumstances of the individual case. A breach of duty may exist, for example, if the managing director pays other creditors in advance or otherwise culpably renders the company unable to meet tax liabilities that are already foreseeable and will become due in the future.
A managing director who has since left office may therefore also be liable. This requires that, during their term of office, they culpably failed to fulfil the duties incumbent upon them.
Tax need not yet have arisen at the time of removal
The BFH clarified that the duty to safeguard funds is not limited to tax claims that have already arisen at the time of removal but are not yet due. It may apply even before the tax claim arises, as soon as its subsequent accrual is foreseeable to the managing director.
For a breach relevant to liability, it is therefore sufficient that:
- the subsequent accrual of the tax is foreseeable at the time of removal; and
- the managing director makes no provision for satisfying the future tax claim.
In the case at issue, at least some of the taxes underlying the liability had not yet arisen at the time of removal. This circumstance did not exclude a possible breach of the duty to safeguard funds.
Special requirements in cases of corporate burial
Where a potentially systematic winding-up process is involved, the decisive question is whether the previous managing director transfers the company’s affairs to a new managing director and, at that time, can recognise on the basis of specific circumstances that the company is intended to be deleted from the register without liquidation or insolvency proceedings.
It must additionally be likely that the company’s tax obligations will no longer be fulfilled. For this purpose, it may be sufficient that tax returns are expected not to be filed, that the tax authorities are then expected to issue estimated assessments and that the assessed taxes are expected not to be paid.
Finanzgericht must investigate the facts further
The BFH was unable to make a final determination as to whether the claimant had breached his duty to safeguard funds. The Finanzgericht had not sufficiently established the factual background to the transfer of management responsibility.
Whereabouts of the company’s assets
As at 31 December 2017, the GmbH had reported work in progress and advance payments received. In the BFH’s view, it had not been clarified how these items developed up to the claimant’s removal or where the corresponding assets remained until the company was deleted from the register.
The balance-sheet items and the company’s subsequent deletion alone did not establish whether assets had been diverted. The Finanzgericht must therefore investigate how the construction projects were actually completed and what happened to the proceeds generated from them.
Financial position at the time of removal
According to the BFH, the finding that the GmbH was not in financial distress in May 2018 was not sufficiently substantiated. The file contained only a balance sheet as at 31 December 2017 and a brief management report as at 31 December 2018. These did not provide sufficient information about the company’s financial position on the date of the removal.
Moreover, financial distress need not already have existed when the managing director was replaced. It could also have been caused only later by a transfer or disappearance of assets.
Ability and willingness of the new managing director
There were also insufficient findings as to whether the new managing director residing in Bulgaria was actually able and willing to continue the projects already under way. In this context, the BFH took into account, among other things, that the application for registration had been translated for him and that the business address initially corresponded to the address at which the claimant was registered as residing at the time.
In the BFH’s view, these circumstances could indicate that the new managing director may not have been intended to manage the company’s affairs himself. The Finanzgericht must determine in the second round of proceedings whether further facts support a different assessment.
Share transfer and subsequent changes of address
The purchase price for the shares transferred in January 2019 and its payment also remained in need of clarification. If no purchase price was agreed or paid and the share transfer had no other economic substance, this could indicate a sham transaction and thus provide a further indication of corporate burial.
According to the judgment, the fact that the business address was not changed until almost 13 months after the removal does not exclude such a process. The sequence of events may be spread over time. The involvement of several managing directors in succession likewise does not preclude a finding of corporate burial, but may indicate a greater degree of concealment.
Former managing director’s duty to cooperate
In the further proceedings, the Finanzgericht must require the claimant to cooperate in establishing the facts. According to the judgment, the relevant events occurred exclusively within his sphere of knowledge and responsibility.
As a general rule, the Finanzamt bears the burden of establishing the facts on which liability is based. However, a decision based on the rules governing the burden of proof may be made only once the required investigations have remained unsuccessful.
If a party breaches its duties to cooperate and material circumstances therefore remain unresolved, the applicable standard of proof may be lowered to that party’s detriment. In the case at issue, it also had to be taken into account that the claimant remained the sole shareholder at least until January 2019 and therefore had comprehensive rights to information and inspection under § 51a GmbHG.
Significance for managing director liability
The judgment distinguishes between the validity of a change of managing director and tax liability for prior conduct. Although removal generally ends a person’s status as legal representative, it does not eliminate potential liability arising from a breach of the duty to safeguard funds committed during the term of office.
The decisive factor is a case-specific examination of the actual sequence of events. This includes, in particular, the company’s foreseeable further development, the whereabouts of its assets, the actual activities of the subsequent management and whether non-compliance with tax obligations had to be anticipated. The Finanzgericht must now re-examine these issues and then rule on liability and the costs of the proceedings.
Distinguishing between a valid termination of office and continuing tax liability may raise extensive factual and tax-law issues. MTR Legal Rechtsanwälte advises companies, managing directors, shareholders and high-net-worth private individuals on such matters as part of its tax law advisory services.