Approximately €5.5 Million in Fines for Collusion Involving Geosynthetics
The Bundeskartellamt (German Federal Cartel Office) has imposed fines totaling approximately €5.5 million on three suppliers of geosynthetics. The companies concerned are G quadrat GmbH, based in Krefeld, Naue Sealing GmbH & Co. KG, based in Espelkamp, and KAT Kunststoff-Abdichtungs-Systeme GmbH, based in Wiesmoor. The proceedings concerned unlawful collusion in the award of contracts for sealing landfill sites.
According to the authority’s findings, executives at Naue Sealing and G quadrat coordinated with representatives of Solmax Geosynthetics GmbH, based in Hamburg, over many years. In addition, an agreement existed with KAT Kunststoff-Abdichtungs-Systeme concerning a single project from 2023.
The fining decisions against the three sanctioned companies are final. All three companies agreed to a consensual conclusion of the proceedings by way of settlement.
Geomembranes for Landfill Sites
Geosynthetics are synthetically manufactured materials used in applications including civil engineering. This product group includes geomembranes. At landfill sites, they are intended to prevent pollutants from entering the soil or groundwater.
Before these geomembranes may be installed at landfill sites, they require approval from the Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM, German Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing). According to the Bundeskartellamt, the four companies involved in the proceedings are the only companies in Germany that distribute appropriately approved geomembranes.
Allocation of Contracts Based on Fixed Quotas
Regular Coordination Since No Later Than 2007
According to the authority’s findings, representatives of Naue Sealing, G quadrat and Solmax Geosynthetics met several times a year from no later than 2007. The purpose of these meetings was to allocate upcoming projects for sealing German landfill sites among themselves.
The participants established fixed shares of the respective contract volume:
- Solmax Geosynthetics was to receive approximately 40 percent of the contract volume.
- Naue Sealing was to receive a share of approximately 35 percent.
- Approximately 25 percent was allocated to G quadrat.
The companies continuously monitored whether these quotas were being observed. According to the Bundeskartellamt’s assessment, this eliminated independent competition for the contracts concerned over an extended period. In a quota cartel, the participants do not compete independently for projects but instead seek to ensure that each company receives its agreed share. In the authority’s assessment, this may result in higher prices and cause significant harm to contracting entities.
Price-Fixing and Cover Bids
To safeguard the intended allocation of contracts, the company to which a project had been assigned determined the prices for certain key products and services or the total tender price. On this basis, the other two companies submitted cover bids.
Where the participants considered it necessary, they also agreed on target prices and minimum prices. This was intended to maintain the price level at a point acceptable to all participating companies.
KAT’s Involvement in a 2023 Project
KAT Kunststoff-Abdichtungs-Systeme only occasionally carried out landfill construction contracts and did not participate in the other parties’ regular meetings. In 2023, however, the other participants allocated a project to the company.
For this specific project, KAT determined the prices on which Naue Sealing, G quadrat and Solmax Geosynthetics based their respective cover bids. The fine imposed on KAT therefore concerns collusion relating to this project rather than the meetings held over many years.
Search Brought the Collusion to an End
According to the Bundeskartellamt’s findings, the arrangements remained in place until September 12, 2023. On that date, the authority conducted a search and disrupted a cartel meeting at a conference hotel.
At this meeting, the company representatives intended to allocate the contracts expected over the following weeks. They also planned to update the project lists they maintained to monitor compliance with the agreed quotas. The infringement ended as a result of the search.
Leniency Program and Cooperation with the Authority
Proceedings Against Solmax Discontinued
The cartel proceedings were initiated following a leniency application by Solmax Geosynthetics. Applying its leniency program, the Bundeskartellamt discontinued the proceedings against this company. Solmax was therefore not fined in these proceedings.
Following the searches, Naue Sealing and G quadrat also cooperated with the Bundeskartellamt under the leniency program. When determining the fines, the authority took into account, among other factors:
- the size of the affected market,
- the size of the companies involved, and
- the scope and quality of each company’s contribution to the cooperation.
Settlement with the Sanctioned Companies
G quadrat, Naue Sealing and KAT each agreed to a consensual conclusion of the proceedings. In cases involving cartel agreements, such a settlement may result in a reduction of the fine by no more than ten percent.
As a general rule, companies may lodge an objection against a fining decision issued by the Bundeskartellamt. The Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf (Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court) decides on the review. No such review remains pending in the present proceedings because all fining decisions are final.
Publication of a Case Report Announced
The Bundeskartellamt has announced that it will publish a case report on its website in the near future containing the information required under § 53 Abs. 5 GWB (Gesetz gegen Wettbewerbsbeschränkungen, German Act against Restraints of Competition). The statutory notice concerning a fining decision for an infringement of § 1 GWB is intended to set out, in particular, the facts established, the nature of the infringement and its duration.
The decision highlights the significant economic consequences that agreements concerning market shares, prices and the award of contracts may entail. Companies and investors with questions about antitrust risks, regulatory proceedings or the implications of a fining decision can obtain legal advice on competition law from MTR Legal.